A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIVJames, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
General
A Whim, and Its Consequences: Collection of British Authors Vol. CXIV
James, G. P. R. (George Payne Rainsford)
Fiction
"But I will make no appeal to your feelings; I will address myself to
your judgment only. I will break through this chain of circumstantial
evidence; I will show that it cannot affect the prisoner, that it is
not applicable to him. I will proceed logically with my inferences;
though it may be somewhat out of the usual course. I will first
convince you that the prisoner was not a man likely to commit such a
crime, by the testimony of many witnesses. I will next prove that
there was no earthly motive for his committing that crime; but every
motive for his not doing so: and, in the end, I will establish beyond
all question that it was impossible that he could have committed it.
Before I proceed to call my witnesses, however, it may be necessary to
examine closely the evidence already adduced, in order that we may
separate the facts clearly and distinctly proved from an immense mass
of irrelevant matter. In so doing, I shall not attempt to explain
every fact and every circumstance; I shall not seek to prove why the
prisoner did this, or why he did that. To do so would occupy
unnecessarily the time and patience of the court. For, surely,
if I establish beyond all doubt, those three great points I have
named--That the prisoner was not a man likely by character,
disposition, and previous conduct, to commit such a crime; secondly,
that he had no possible motive for committing it; but the reverse: and
thirdly, that if the testimony already given be not altogether false,
he could not have committed it, that will be quite sufficient for the
satisfaction of the court.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account