A Woman's Quest: The life of Marie E. Zakrzewska, M.D.Zakrzewska, Marie E. (Marie Elizabeth)
History
A Woman's Quest: The life of Marie E. Zakrzewska, M.D.
Zakrzewska, Marie E. (Marie Elizabeth)
Women physicians -- United States -- Biography; Zakrzewska, Marie E. (Marie Elizabeth), 1829-1902
Dr. Storer’s letter containing his resignation was remarkable for its
expressions of misunderstanding of the resolutions quoted above and for
its misrepresentation of the general charitable policy of the Hospital.
But it was chiefly remarkable for the needlessly offensive manner in
which the writer revealed his personal disapproval of the study of
medicine by women. Yet he condescended on second thought to qualify the
latter statement, by adding:
For certain of the professional ladies whom I have met, I have
personally the highest respect and esteem. Miss Zakrzewska, the
beauty and purity of whose life as already published to the world I
have long seen verified, may well challenge comparison in practice
with a certain percentage of my own sex. Miss Tyng, now for two
years my assistant in private practice, has such natural tastes and
inclinations as fit her, more than I should have supposed any woman
could have become fitted, for the anxieties, the nervous strain and
the shocks of the practice of surgery. And there are others not now
officially connected with the Hospital whose names I would mention in
terms of similar commendation.
Such are, however, at the best, but very exceptional cases, and I am
driven back to my old belief, the same that is entertained by the mass
of mankind, that in claiming this especial work of medicine women have
mistaken their calling.
An interesting by-action of the writer was his concurrent sending of
this extraordinary letter of resignation to the _Boston Medical and
Surgical Journal_ for publication. This journal has already been
quoted as being opposed to the entrance of women into the medical
profession, and at this time and for many subsequent years, it still
continued its attitude of opposition.
It is of a certain interest to note here that Dr. Storer once more
emerged in public to express his sex-peculiar views regarding women
physicians. This was in San Francisco in 1871, when, at the annual
meeting of the American Medical Association, the question of women
as delegates and members was brought into the debate upon a related
subject. In the discussion, Dr. Storer spoke in opposition, saying:
... We will grant that some exceptional women are as interested in
our science as ourselves; that some of them have those peculiar
qualities, that especial temperament, that gives them not merely a
taste for anatomy and surgery but courage to face the greatest dangers
and anxiety in surgery; and that there are some women who are able
to go out in inclement weather and brave the storm. We may grant
that women, some of them, may have had peculiar means or favorable
opportunities which allow them to get this same education that men
have. We may grant, and grant it freely, that in some matters, women
intellectually, are as completely mistresses of their subject as we
are masters of ours.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account