Russia -- History -- Revolution, 1905-1907; Russia -- Politics and government -- 1894-1917; Russia -- Social conditions -- 1801-1917
“We must have a Constitution, just as we have an Army and a Navy,
because the idea soothes the revolution-haunted breasts of foreign
financiers, but we shall never have a real Constitution because we don’t
want one. Reforms? Oh, yes, as many as you please, on paper, signed and
countersigned, but they will remain a dead letter, because they are not
adapted to the character and the spirit of the nation. You cannot force
Russian peasants to own land in the way Western peasants do. You can
make laws telling them to do so, but if you force them you will only
drive them to rebellion. Russia is like China; you can draw up a
Constitution for Russia, but when it is carried out you will find that
the only practical difference between the old state of affairs and the
new is that the writing-table of the Minister of Foreign Affairs is to
be oblong instead of round. People say that the Russian people is good
and that its Government is bad, but the faults of the people are not the
result of the inherent vices of the Government; the vices of the
Government are the logical result of the faults, which in their turn are
the inevitable complement of the good qualities, of the people. The
desire for Liberal reforms based on Western examples is merely a
fictitious agitation of a minority, namely, the ‘Intelligenzia’ or
middle class, who have forgotten and lost their native traditions and
instincts and have adopted and not properly assimilated the traditions
and instincts of Western Europe. They have ceased to be Russian, and
they have not become European. They have taken the European banner of
ideals, but they do not know what to do with it; they cannot hold it up
in their weak Slav hands. The result is words, words, words. This
chatter will continue for a time, and when people get tired of
listening, it will cease. As for the people, the real people, they will
settle their affairs with those immediately connected with them, with
their landlords, &c. The Government will make plenty of reforms on paper
and have a Duma; but everything will go on exactly as it was before.
Because you cannot change the character of a people, and the form of
government they enjoy is the result and the expression of their
qualities and of their defects.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account