English fiction -- 20th century; Short stories, English
“By your leave,” he said, “there is little moderation desirable when we
are face to face with real suffering, and, as a general rule, no time
like the present.”
“But there is, as you were saying just now, such a thing as a sense of
proportion. I cannot see that it’s my business to excite myself about
the caging of larks when there are so many much greater evils.”
“Forgive my saying so,” he answered, “but if, when a caged lark comes
under your nose, excitement does not take hold of you, with or against
your will, there is mighty little chance of your getting excited about
anything. For, consider what it means to be a caged lark--what pining
and misery for that little creature, which only lives for its life up
in the blue. Consider what blasphemy against Nature, and what an insult
to all that is high and poetic in man, it is to cage such an exquisite
thing of freedom!”
“You forget that it is done out of love for the song--to bring it into
towns where people can’t otherwise hear it.”
“It is done for a living--and that people without imagination may
squeeze out of unhappy creatures a little gratification!”
“It is not a crime to have no imagination.”
“No, sir; but neither is the lack of it a thing to pride oneself on, or
pass by in silence, when it inflicts suffering.”
“I am not defending the custom of caging larks.”
“No; but you are responsible for its continuance.”
“I?”
“You and all those other people who believe in minding their own
business.”
“Really,” I said; “you must not attack people on that ground. We cannot
all be busybodies!”
“The saints forbid!” he answered. “But when a thing exists which you
really abhor--as you do this--I do wish you would consider a little
whether, in letting it strictly alone, you are minding your own
business on principle, or because it is so jolly comfortable to do so.”
“Speaking for myself----”
“Yes,” he broke in; “quite! But let me ask you one thing: Have
you, as a member of the human race, any feeling that you share
in the advancement of its gentleness, of its sense of beauty and
justice--that, in proportion as the human race becomes more lovable and
lovely, you too become more lovable and lovely?”
“Naturally.”
“Then is it not your business to support all that you feel makes for
that advancing perfection?”
“I don’t say that it isn’t.”
“In that case it is _not_ your business to stop your ears, and shut
your eyes, and hold your tongue, when you come across wild song-birds
caged.”
But we had reached my rooms.
“Before I go in,” I said, “there is just one little thing I’ve got
to say to you: Don’t you think that, for a man with your ‘sense
of proportion,’ you exaggerate the importance of beasts and their
happiness?”
He looked at me for a long time without speaking, and when he did speak
it was in a queer, abstracted voice:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account