Accepting the universe : $b Essays in naturalismBurroughs, John
Philosophy
Accepting the universe : $b Essays in naturalism
Burroughs, John
Natural history; Natural history -- Philosophy; Philosophy; Science
How has the problem of evil tried men’s souls! How have their
gods failed to live up to the character they have given them! How
have they confused our moral standards! The trouble lies in a
misconception of the nature of evil, and in a false idea of the
universe itself.
There is no problem of evil until we have made or imagined an
unnatural and impossible world. When we have enthroned in the
universe a powerful man-made God who is the embodiment of all we
call good and the contemner of all we call evil, then we have our
insoluble problem. To help ourselves out we invent another being who
is the embodiment of all we call evil and enthrone him in regions
below. Upon him we saddle the evil, and thus we try to run the
universe with these two antagonistic principles yoked together, and
no end of confusion in our religious ideas results.
The moment we postulate an all-loving, all-merciful, all-wise, and
just being to rule the affairs of this world, and place him in such
intimate relations with it that not a sparrow falls to the ground
without his will and cognizance, then, indeed, are we in troubled
waters and have lost our reckoning. We cannot excuse such being on
the ground that his ways are inscrutable and past finding out. A
creator who sends into the world the malformed, the half-witted, the
bestial, the naturally depraved, and then holds them to high ethical
standards, is condemned by the ideals which he has implanted within
us.
Now the naturalist has no such trouble. He sees that good and evil
are only relative terms; that they both grow on the same tree; that
we should not know good were there no evil; that there would be no
development were there not what we call evil. Pain and suffering
are inseparable from the human lot. They are a part of the price
we pay for our place in the world. All struggle we look upon as
evil. Disease, failure, death are looked upon as evil, but they
are conditions of our lives. Through sickness we learn the laws
of health. The lower animals have no such troubles--no sickness,
intemperance, or war or avarice. They know without reason how to
live, but man has reason, and the joy of its exercise and the peril
of its failure. Are we not all willing to pay the price?--to take it
on these terms rather than to change places with the brutes?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account