Accepting the universe : $b Essays in naturalismBurroughs, John
Philosophy
Accepting the universe : $b Essays in naturalism
Burroughs, John
Natural history; Natural history -- Philosophy; Philosophy; Science
Tennyson’s agonizing line “Nature red in tooth and claw” tends,
especially in the days of world-wide human carnage, to make one see
the whole animal kingdom with blood-dripping claws and jaws. But it
is not so. At its worst this “tooth and claw” business applies only
to a fraction of wild life. The vast army of the seed-eaters, the
plant-eaters, the fruit-eaters, upon which the flesh-eaters subsist,
and which they help keep in check, is greatly in the ascendancy.
The whole truth of this matter of the cruelty of Nature may be put
in a nutshell: Nature as seen in animal life is _sanguinary_, but
only man is _cruel_. Only man deliberately and intentionally inflicts
pain; only man tortures his victims, and takes pleasure in their
agony. No other creature goes out of its way to inflict suffering; no
other creature acts from the motive of cruelty or the will to give
pain.
Nature kills, but does not torture. The biological laws are neither
human nor inhuman; they are _un_human. If in following the rule that
might makes right, the Germans sought justification by an appeal to
biological laws, they fell below the beasts of the fields, because
they are moral beings, and know good from evil.
Biological laws are not concerned about the moral law. Not till
we reach man’s moral nature does this law have any validity; then
it becomes a biological law, because it has survival value. Could
the race of man ever have developed as we now see it without
the conceptions of right and justice and the spirit of mutual
helpfulness? As time passes, other things being equal, the most
righteous and humanitarian nation will be the most powerful and the
most progressive. The great strength of the Allied cause in the World
War was that it was founded upon an ideal conception of international
justice and comity. President Wilson set this forth in such wonderful
completeness that it will shine in our political firmament for all
time like a star of the first magnitude. And the weakness of the
German cause was that it was based upon the spirit and the aims of
the pirate and the highwayman.
When we speak of Nature’s cruelty we are obsessed with the idea that
blood and death necessarily mean cruelty, whereas cruelty, as I have
said, means an intentional infliction of pain or suffering. Is the
surgeon cruel when he performs an operation? Do our own carnivorous
habits imply cruelty? The slaughter-house is not a pleasant object
to contemplate; the sight of blood disturbs most of us; its sight
and smell excite even the unreasoning brutes. But it is the wanton
shedding of blood that reacts unfavorably upon ourselves, and makes
us indifferent to the suffering which blood so often implies. Life is
a wonderful and precious gift, and we do not like to see it wantonly
destroyed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account