Alcohol: A Dangerous and Unnecessary Medicine, How and Why: What Medical Writers SayAllen, Martha Meir
Science
Alcohol: A Dangerous and Unnecessary Medicine, How and Why: What Medical Writers Say
Allen, Martha Meir
Alcohol -- Physiological effect; Temperance
"In connection with this subject it might be mentioned that, for
years past, the name of Bellevue Hospital has been taken in vain
by a number of persons and firms, without any authority
whatever. It is a common occurrence that samples of proprietary
medicines, foods, mineral waters, plasters, etc., etc. are sent
to the hospital, or to members of the house-staff for 'trial,'
whereupon the subsequent advertisements of the articles in
question often assert that the latter are 'used in Bellevue
Hospital,' leaving the impression upon the mind of the reader
that the article, or articles, have been used with the sanction
of some member of the Medical Board. It is probably impossible
to find a remedy for this evil, from which many other
institutions of repute likewise suffer. To publish a denial of
such false assertions would only aggravate the evil. The utmost
that can be done appears to be, to caution the medical staff
against any entanglements with, or encouragement of, the agents
of the interested parties."
This report, which was adopted by the Medical Board of Bellevue
Hospital, classifies proprietary preparations as "Objectionable" or
"Unobjectionable" according to the following rules:--
"Unobjectionable preparations are those, the origin and
composition of which is not kept secret, and which are known to
serve a useful and legitimate purpose. Malted Milk is an
example. Objectionable proprietary preparations, by far the
largest group of the whole class, comprise all those which are
aimed at under the medical code of ethics under the term 'secret
nostrum,' which term may be more closely defined thus:
"A secret nostrum is a preparation, the origin or composition of
which is kept secret, the therapeutic claims for which are
unreasonable or unscientific, or which is not intended for a
legitimate purpose.
"Examples: The various 'Soothing Syrups,' 'Female Regulators,'
'Blood Purifiers,' and thousands of others."
Dr. A. Emil Hiss, Ph. G., says of the secrecy of these preparations:--
"A secret compound with a meaningless title is presumptively a
fraud. Why a secret if not to permit extravagant, or fraudulent,
claims as to therapeutic merit? * * * * * The ruling motive of
the secret being essentially false and dishonest, its employment
in the interest of any remedy is clearly a sufficient cause for
its condemnation and ostracism."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account