Americanization; Civics; Immigrants -- United States; Naturalization -- United States; Noncitizens -- United States
Every applicant shall satisfy the court that he is familiar
with, and attached to, such sentiments as are expressed in such
writings as “A Man Without a Country,” “America,” “Declaration
of Independence,” etc., and that he is possessed of reasonable
opinions on necessity of government and duty of citizens to
support the government and its laws, the freedom of the press,
liberty of speech, obtaining redress for grievances, and a firm
opposition to rioting, violence, force, and secret societies or
orders countenancing or teaching overthrow of the government.
An Iowa judge says:
“Search the heart for the truth.” The chief thing is to have the
heart right--to have love and attachment for liberty, justice, and
humanity, and to be ready to die, if need be, for the maintenance
thereof. It might be well to have a uniform course of instruction
for applicants for citizenship, but I would not adhere to it too
strictly, if the heart proved to be right.... No good man, a true
lover of liberty, justice, and humanity, should be rejected, unless
he utterly fails to meet the other requirements of the law.
A Pennsylvania judge thinks little of educational requirements; that
they would exclude many desirable applicants.
The principle test that I apply is as to the honesty of the party.
Under an intellectual test many honest, hard-working men would
fail, while men who had the advantage of education would secure
naturalization.... Where men are required to support a family and
labor hard they have not much time to study.
A judge in Nebraska, who handles some 200 cases a year, declares:
The intellect is not a test of good citizenship. I know many people
with insufficient intellect to procure much education, who cannot
read nor write, who are excellent citizens; and many others who are
highly educated and too crooked to make good citizens.
A California judge avers:
My observation has been that many of our best citizens are those
who possess no extended education, and some of the most dangerous
are of those who possess high educational qualifications.
A judge in central New York, who has large experience with
naturalization, says:
Too much stress is laid upon information concerning the details
of our governmental system, and not enough upon the candidate’s
personal record, endeavors, and results. An Italian laborer who has
been unable to learn the number of Houses into which Congress is
divided, but is hard-working, steady, possessed of a desire to own
his home and bring his family up in our ways, is more useful to us
than some of more intelligence.
He holds that the principal difficulty with which desirable
immigrants have to contend, in seeking naturalization, is the fact
that “too much technical information is demanded by the young men who
represent the Bureau of Naturalization.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account