An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
There is another reason for attempting to discover an instrument of
reasoning (that is, of gaining new truths by means of old), which may
be less vague and arbitrary than the talent and experience of the few
or the common-sense of the many. As memory is not always accurate, and
has on that account led to the adoption of writing, as being a _memoria
technica_, unaffected by the failure of mental impressions,—as our
senses at times deceive us, and have to be corrected by each other; so
is it also with our reasoning faculty. The conclusions of one man are
not the conclusions of another; those of the same man do not always
agree together; those of ever so many who agree together may differ
from the facts themselves, which those conclusions are intended to
ascertain. In consequence it becomes a necessity, if it be possible,
to analyze the process of reasoning, and to invent a method which may
act as a common measure between mind and mind, as a means of joint
investigation, and as a recognized intellectual standard,—a standard
such as to secure us against hopeless mistakes, and to emancipate us
from the capricious _ipse dixit_ of authority.
As the index on the dial notes down the sun’s course in the heavens,
as a key, revolving through the intricate wards of the lock, opens for
us a treasure-house, so let us, if we can, provide ourselves with some
ready expedient to serve as a true record of the system of objective
truth, and an available rule for interpreting its phenomena; or at
least let us go as far as we can in providing it. One such experimental
key is the science of geometry, which, in a certain department of
nature, substitutes a collection of true principles, fruitful and
interminable in consequences, for the guesses, _pro re natâ_, of our
intellect, and saves it both the labour and the risk of guessing.
Another far more subtle and effective instrument is algebraical
science, which acts as a spell in unlocking for us, without merit or
effort of our own individually, the _arcana_ of the concrete physical
universe. A more ambitious, because a more comprehensive contrivance
still, for interpreting the concrete world is the method of logical
inference. What we desiderate is something which may supersede the need
of personal gifts by a far-reaching and infallible rule. Now, without
external symbols to mark out and to steady its course, the intellect
runs wild; but with the aid of symbols, as in algebra, it advances with
precision and effect. Let then our symbols be words: let all thought
be arrested and embodied in words. Let language have a monopoly of
thought; and thought go for only so much as it can show itself to be
worth in language. Let every prompting of the intellect be ignored,
every _momentum_ of argument be disowned, which is unprovided with an
equivalent wording, as its ticket for sharing in the common search
after truth. Let the authority of nature, common-sense, experience,
genius, go for nothing.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account