------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | | | Mon-| Other | | | Animals. | Dogs.| Cats.|keys.|Animals.| Total.| |---------------------------------|------|------|-----|--------|-------| | I. Number used for original | | | | | | | research only, by: | | | | | | | Dr. X. .. .. .. | | | | | | | Dr. Y. .. .. .. | | | | | | | II. Number used for demonstra- | | | | | | | tions before students, by: | | | | | | | Dr. A. .. .. .. | | | | | | | Dr. B. .. .. .. | | | | | | |III. Number used by students for | | | | | | | observation of physiolog- | | | | | | | ical phenomena, etc. .. | | | | | | | |------|------|-----|--------|-------| | Total .. .. .. | | | | | | | |------|------|-----|--------|-------| | Number of above animals to | | | | | | | which curare was given, in | | | | | | | course of experimentation .. | | | | | | ------------------------------------------------------------------------ (Signed) ..................... DIRECTOR OF LABORATORY. STATE OF NEW YORK. CITY OF NEW YORK. SS. On this 1st day of April, 1920, before me, the subscriber, personally came C. D., known to me, who, being duly sworn, declared that the foregoing report signed by him, is a full, true and complete statement of the disposition of all animals experimented upon in the laboratories of the Carnegie Institute, during the quarter-year ending March 31, 1920, to the best of his knowledge and belief. ..................... NOTARY PUBLIC. APPENDIX III It is exceedingly probably that no young physician or medical student could testify to cruelties witnessed in any physiological laboratory, if they involved his instructors or fellow-students, without injuring and perhaps ruining altogether his professional career. Only in later years, when success and independence have been attained, can he venture to speak freely of what he has seen. Some men have thus spoken. The testimony of two is here given: Rev. Frederic Rowland Marvin, M.D., Albany, N.Y.: