Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Classical literature -- History and criticism -- Theory, etc.; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Ancient
The same promotive guidance appears in the assigning of outlines
(_materiæ_), less and less ample as the pupils advance, for written
composition (II. vi). This writing was generally for practise, not for
casting a particular speech in form to be memorized. Sometimes, says
Quintilian, the boys may recite what they have written out; but generally
learning by heart is better spent on the orators and historians than on
their own work (vii).
The _declamatio_ recommended by Quintilian is speaking from outline on
hypothetical cases. The more elementary assignments, for deliberative
speeches, were called _suasoriæ_; the more advanced, for forensic
speeches, _controversiæ_. Both he treats only as school exercises. Within
these limits he recommends _declamatio_ as an important pedagogical
discovery.
“So soon as [the youth] is well taught and sufficiently
exercised in these first tasks, themselves not small, but as
it were members and parts of greater ones, let the time demand
the essaying of deliberative speaking and forensic on assigned
outlines. Before I go into the method of these, I must tell
briefly what _declamatio_ has as its idea, which is at once
the most recent discovery and far the most useful. For it at
once embraces almost all the exercises just discussed and
offers the nearest likeness to actuality. Therefore it has
become so popular as to be in the opinion of many sufficient
of itself to develop eloquence. Nor can there be found any
mastery in consecutive discourse which is not related to
this exercise in speaking. True, the actual practise has so
declined by the fault of teachers that among the chief causes
corrupting eloquence have been the license and ignorance of
_declamatores_; but we may use well what is essentially good.
“Let the outlines of the fictitious cases assigned be therefore
as like as possible to actuality; and let the _declamatio_,
so far as possible, imitate those pleas for which it was
invented to prepare. Wizards, pestilence, oracles, stepmothers
more cruel than those of tragedy, and other topics even more
imaginary, we seek in vain among real law cases. What, then?
Are we never to permit a young man to elaborate themes outside
of statistics, even poetical ones, such indeed as I myself have
mentioned, that he may have room, take some pleasure in the
assignment, and enter as it were into the body [of the party he
defends]? That used to be all very well; but at least let such
[exercises] be grand and swelling without being silly and to
critical eyes ridiculous.” II. x. 1-6.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account