Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Ancient rhetoric and poetic : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Classical literature -- History and criticism -- Theory, etc.; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Ancient
Quintilian’s long discussion of style (_elocutio_, VIII-XI) opens
with one of his best sayings, “let care in words be solicitude for
things”;[13] and the whole introduction is an admirable answer to the
old quibble about form and substance. If he thereupon proceeds for two
books by the usual categories, he at least avoids the subdivision that
had become excessive, and provides a convenient guide to the voluminous
classical lore of _elocutio_.[14] Typical is his introduction, under
sentence-movement (_compositio_, IX. iv), to the doctrine of sentence
close (_clausula_).
[“Though rhythm must be pervasive] it is more demanded in
closing cadences (_in clausulis_) and more obvious; first,
because every thought has its own conclusion and demands a
natural pause to separate it from the beginning of the one that
follows; and furthermore, because the ear, having followed an
oral sequence, having been guided by the current of flowing
prose, is more critical when that movement stops and gives time
to consider. Neither hard, therefore, nor abrupt should be the
place where the attention takes breath and is renewed. Here is
the dwelling-place of prose; here is the point to which the
audience looks forward; here speaks the orator’s whole merit.”
IX. iv. 61-62. (The text of the last sentence is dubious;
but the general intention of exalting the importance of the
_clausula_ is clear.)
(7) _Style Promoted_
Having followed the usual analysis of style, Quintilian proceeds (X)
to constructive promotion, to the ways of gaining secure control
(_firma facilitas_; see the tabular view, page 66). “We who contemplate
oratorical power, not mountebank volubility, have to inculcate both
range and discrimination” (_copia cum iudicio_, X. i. 8). So the vivid
impressions that come through the ear should be supplemented by critical
reading. The reading of poetry promotes concrete realization, heightening
of style, emotional appeal, and aptness in characterization.[15] From
imitation Quintilian passes (X. iii) to writing for practise in style.
Since this, like deep plowing, is for a better yield, he goes into
specific counsels.
Repeat what you have just written, both for connection and
to warm up afresh. Fluency comes from habit, not from haste.
You will not learn to write well by writing rapidly; you will
learn to write rapidly by writing well. Lolling and looking at
the ceiling will not answer; you must follow a plan (_ratio_).
Rapid extempore draft (_silva_) has this disadvantage, that
subsequent revision, though it may amend words and rhythm, is
likely to leave the superficiality (_levitas_) that has arisen
from hasty crowding. Better exercise prevision, and so conduct
your work (_opus ducere_) from the beginning that revision
shall be polishing, not entirely making over.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account