Animal intelligence: Experimental studiesThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
Animal intelligence: Experimental studies
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Animal intelligence; Psychology, Comparative
If a monkey did actually form an association between a given situation
and act by seeing some one respond to that situation by that act, it
would be evidence of considerable importance concerning his general
mental status, for it would go to show that he could and often did form
associations between sense-impressions and ideas and between ideas and
acts. Seeing some one turn a key in a lock might thus give him the
idea of turning or moving the key, and this idea might arouse the act.
However, the mere fact that a monkey does something which you have just
done in his presence need not demonstrate or even render a bit more
probable such a general mental condition. For he perhaps would have acted
in just the same manner if you had offered him no model. If you put
two toothpicks on a dish, take one and put it in your mouth, a monkey
will do the same, not because he profits by your example, but because
he instinctively puts nearly all small objects in his mouth. Because of
their general activity, their instinctive impulses to grab, drop, bite,
rub, carry, move about, turn over, etc., any novel object within their
reach, their constant movement and assumption of all sorts of postures,
the monkeys perform many acts like our own and simulate imitation to a
far greater extent than other mammals.
Even if a monkey which has failed of itself to do a certain thing does it
after you have shown him the act, there need be no reason to suppose that
he is learning by imitation, forming an association between the sight of
the object and the act towards it through an idea gained from watching
you. You may have caused his act simply by attracting his attention to
the object. Perhaps if you had pointed at it or held it passively in your
hand, you would have brought to pass just the same action on his part.
There are several cases among my records where an act which an animal
failed totally to do of himself was done after I had so attracted his
attention to the object concerned.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account