Animal intelligence: Experimental studiesThorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Science
Animal intelligence: Experimental studies
Thorndike, Edward L. (Edward Lee)
Animal intelligence; Psychology, Comparative
We should expect to find the tendency to imitation more obvious in the
case of young and parents than elsewhere. I have had no chance to observe
such cases. We should expect closely associated animals, such as members
of a common troop or animals on friendly terms, to manifest it more
than others. Unfortunately, two of my monkeys, by the time I was ready
to make definite experiments, were on terms of war. The other had then
become so shy that I could not confidently infer inability to do a thing
from actual failure to do it. He showed no evidence of learning from his
mates. I have, therefore, little evidence of a quantitative objective
nature to present and shall have in the end to ask the reader to take
some opinions without verifiable proofs.
My reliable experiments, five in number, were of the following nature. A
monkey who had failed of himself (and often also after a chance to learn
from me or from being put through the act) would be put where he could
see another do the act and get a reward (food) for it. He would then be
given a chance to do it himself, and note would be taken of his success
or failure, and of whether his act was the same as that of his model in
case he succeeded, and of whether he tried that act more than before the
tuition in case he tried it and failed. The results are given in Table 11.
In the fourth experiment No. 1 showed further that the tuition did not
cause his successes in that after some successes further tuition did not
improve him.
There is clearly no evidence here of any imitation of No. 1 by No. 3.
There was also apparently nothing like purposive watching on the part
of No. 3. He seemed often to see No. 1 open the box or work the chute
mechanism, but without special interest.
This lack of any special curiosity about the doings of their own species
characterized the general behavior of all three of my monkeys and in
itself lessens the probability that they learn much from one another. Nor
did there appear, in the course of the three months and more the animals
were together, any signs of imitation. There were indeed certain notable
instances of the lack of it in circumstances which one would suppose
would be favorable cases for it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account