Anti-Semitism in the United States : $b Its history and causesLevinger, Lee J. (Lee Joseph)
History
Anti-Semitism in the United States : $b Its history and causes
Levinger, Lee J. (Lee Joseph)
Antisemitism -- United States; Jews -- United States
The most important reaction to anti-Semitism is the unconscious mode
of response which we call the inferiority complex. Certainly the Jew
has such a complex. He alternates boldness and timidity, because he is
self-conscious in the presence of the non-Jew and therefore uncertain
of himself. Jews change their names from land to land, assuming the
Russian “witz” or the Polish “sky” for the previous German “sohn” as
a patronymic—for all Jewish names were originally in the Hebrew form
of Isaac ben (son of) Abraham; but when they come to the United
States the “witz” and “sky” are foreign and many of them are dropped in
turn. The Hebrew Moses becomes the German Morris, and then the English
Montague. This is partly due to the adoption of the standard of taste
of the new environment, partly to the desire not to be too aggressively
Jewish in externals. As Friedman shows:
[106]The Jew is the underdog of society ... he has acquired a social
sympathy and has become spiritually attuned to the harmonies of a
juster social order. [107]Anti-Semitism is a challenge to Jewry to
revivify its ideals. [108]Danger strengthens family ties. Perhaps the
pure and devoted family life for which the Jews have been noted may
be due to the fact that they preserved this defensive reaction of a
group under persecution. [109]Persecution has left the mark of fear on
the psychology of the Jew.... The Jew retired into himself, or to the
society of his kind.
In the present state of ignorance, I cannot state how much of the
Jewish character is hereditary and how much environmental, or how
much of the latter is due to the inferiority complex and hence to
anti-Semitism. Certainly there must be many traits of this origin.
Thomas Babington Macaulay made this discovery in 1833, when he argued
in the House of Commons in favor of removing civil disabilities from
the Jews of England.
... If all the red-haired people in Europe had, during centuries, been
outraged and oppressed, banished from this place, driven from that
... if, when manners became milder, they had still been subject to
debasing restrictions and exposed to vulgar insults ... what would be
the patriotism of gentlemen with red hair?
Ludwig Lewisohn finds exactly such an artificial case in the
German-Americans during the World War:
[110]I (the German) know exactly now why you (the Jew) and your people
are accused of bad manners. How can one’s manners be good when all
agreement and social certainties are lacking? Whatever one does will
be considered an excess.... So I am beginning to understand the
voluntary and yet involuntary segregation of Jewry.
To which the Jew retorts:
The worst of it is that we are all super-sensitive because we are
neurasthenic.... There is scarcely a Jewish family in which there
isn’t either madness or genius. Commonly both.
Professor Miller generalizes this into a theory of “oppression
psychosis,” mentioned above:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account