Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathyPodmore, Frank
Philosophy
Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathy
Podmore, Frank
Apparitions; Telepathy
The present case well illustrates the difficulties attendant on any
efforts to procure reliable contemporary evidence for psychical events.
Even when, as here, the percipient himself took the right course, from
the standpoint of psychical research, his forethought was to a great
extent frustrated by the shortcomings of his friend.
With this narrative may be compared three cases given in _Phantasms
of the Living_ (vol. i. pp. 280 _et seq._) of the occurrence of
exceptional distress to one twin at the time of the death of the other.
Mr. Leveson Gower has sent us an account of a similar marked fit of
depression, accompanied by "a vivid sense of the presence of death,"
which coincided with the quite sudden and unlooked-for death of a near
relation, the late Lady Marion Alford. (_Journal S.P.R._, May 1888.)
Professor Tamburini records an analogous case. A lunatic died in the
asylum at Reggio on the 21st May 1892. A letter of inquiry, dated the
22nd May, was received at the asylum from the husband, who had not
previously written for more than a year; and it was ascertained that he
was prompted to write the letter by a feeling of "great discomfort, as
though some misfortune were about to befall him," experienced on the
previous day, the day of the death.
No. 49.--From Dr N., of New York State.
The next case is specially interesting, because the emotion which was
felt in the first instance was succeeded by a visual impression of a
detailed kind. This case again comes to us from America (_Proc. Am.
S.P.R._, pp. 397-400). Dr. N., the percipient, writes to Professor
Royce as follows:--
[Postmarked _Aug._ 16, 1886.]
"In the convalescence from a malarial fever during which great
hyperæsthesia of brain had obtained, but no hallucinations or false
perceptions, I was sitting alone in my room looking out of the
window. My thoughts were of indifferent trivialities; after a time
my mind seemed to become absolutely vacant; my eyes felt fixed,
the air seemed to grow white. I could see objects about me, but it
was a terrible effort of _will_ to perceive anything. I then felt
great and painful sense as of sympathy with some one suffering,
who or where I did not know. After a little time I knew with whom,
but how I knew I cannot tell; for it seemed some time after this
knowledge of personality that I saw distinctly, in my brain, _not_
before my eyes, a large, square room, evidently in a hotel, and saw
the person of whom I had been conscious, lying face downward on the
bed in the throes of mental and physical anguish. I felt rather
than heard sobs and grieving, and felt conscious of the nature of
the grief subjectively; its objective cause was not transmitted to
me. Extreme exhaustion followed the experience, which lasted forty
minutes intensely, and then very slowly wore away. Let me note:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account