Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathyPodmore, Frank
Philosophy
Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathy
Podmore, Frank
Apparitions; Telepathy
"On the following Sunday, when Scott and I returned from church and
went into the ante-room, Campbell, who was there, asked us both
to try and remember anything peculiar that he had told us on the
1st. After a little time, we remembered about the dream, and he
(Campbell) then showed us the _Times_ newspaper of the day before,
containing the notice of Major Hubbersty's death, at Penzance, on
November 30th, 1886, the same date as that on which he had the
dream; also, I remember, he (Campbell) told us that in his vision
he seemed to see the clothes which Major Hubbersty had on, and that
there was a red thread running through the pattern of the trousers."
The two other friends mentioned by Captain Campbell, Messrs. Leeper and
Scott, have written letters to the same effect.[91]
From these letters there can be no doubt that the coincidence made a
marked impression on each of those to whom the dream was related, and
this fact, perhaps even more than Captain Campbell's own narrative, is
a striking proof of the exceptional nature of the experience.
There is no reason in this case for supposing that the dream conveyed
any other information than the fact of the agent's death. There is
no evidence that the manner of death or the clothes worn by Major
Hubbersty resembled what was seen in the dream. The clothes in which
the figure appeared may have been a reminiscence of clothes which the
percipient had actually seen worn on some occasion by the agent. But
this explanation will hardly apply to the following case, where the
dream included a representation, accurate in more than one particular,
of the agent as he actually appeared at the time. It is true that
we have to rely upon the percipient's memory after the interval of
a fortnight for the details of the dream, but since the dream was
sufficiently impressive to cause a note to be taken of it by a person
not in the habit of making such notes, it seems not unreasonable to
trust the memory to that extent.
No, 58.--From MR. E. W. HAMILTON, C.B.
"PARK LANE CHAMBERS, PARK LANE, W.,
_April_ 6_th_, 1888.
"On Wednesday morning, March 21st, 1888, I woke up with the
impression of a very vivid dream. I had dreamt that my brother,
who had long been in Australia, and of whom I had heard nothing
for several months, had come home; that after an absence of twelve
years and a half he was very little altered in appearance, but that
he had something wrong with one of his arms; it looked horribly red
near the wrist, his hand being bent back.
"When I got up that morning the dream recurred constantly to
my thoughts, and I at last determined to take a note of it,
notwithstanding my natural prejudices against attaching any
importance to dreams, to which, indeed, I am not much subject.
Accordingly, in the course of the day, I made in my little Letts'
diary a mark thus: X, with my brother's name after it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account