Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathyPodmore, Frank
Philosophy
Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathy
Podmore, Frank
Apparitions; Telepathy
"Your lady's Fanny; well, there is a Fanny. [No.] Fred has light
hair, brownish moustache, prominent nose. [No.] Your thesis was
some special thing. I should say about lungs." [No.]
_At Sitting_ 43:--
"Your mother's name was Elizabeth. [No.] Her father's lame. [No.]
Of your children there's Eddie and Willie and Fannie or Annie and
a sister that faints, and Willie and Katie (no, Katie don't count)
[being the nurse], and Harry and the little dark-eyed one, Daisy.
[All wrong except Daisy.] One passed out with sore throat. [No.]
The boy looks about 8. [No, 4.] Your wife's father had something
wrong with leg; one named William. [No.] Your grandmother had a
sister who married a Howe--Henry Howe. [Unknown.] There's a Thomson
connected with you [no], and if you look you will find a Howe too.
Your brother the captain [correct], with a lovely wife, who has
brown hair [correct], has had trouble in head [no], and has two
girls and a boy." [No, three girls.]
In this case it will be seen that no details were given which could not
have been derived from the conscious knowledge of the sitter. Apart
from the fact that the agent made no effort to impress his thought, it
resembles a case of ordinary telepathy. Of much the same character are
the following details, quoted from Professor James's account of his
interviews with Mrs. Piper (_Proc. S.P.R._, vol. vi. pp. 658, 659):--
No. 97.--From Professor W. JAMES.
"The most convincing things said about my own immediate household
were either very intimate or very trivial. Unfortunately the former
things cannot well be published. Of the trivial things, I have
forgotten the greater number, but the following, _raræ nantes_, may
serve as samples of their class: She said that we had lost recently
a rug, and I a waistcoat. [She wrongly accused a person of stealing
the rug, which was afterwards found in the house.] She told of my
killing a grey-and-white cat, with ether, and described how it had
'spun round and round' before dying. She told how my New York aunt
had written a letter to my wife, warning her against all mediums,
and then went off on a most amusing criticism, full of _traits
vifs_, of the excellent woman's character. [Of course no one but
my wife and I knew the existence of the letter in question.] She
was strong on the events in our nursery, and gave striking advice
during our first visit to her about the way to deal with certain
'tantrums' of our second child, 'little Billy-boy,' as she called
him, reproducing his nursery name. She told how the crib creaked
at night, how a certain rocking-chair creaked mysteriously, how my
wife had heard footsteps on the stairs, etc., etc. Insignificant as
these things sound when read, the accumulation of a large number
of them has an irresistible effect. And I repeat again what I
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account