Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathyPodmore, Frank
Philosophy
Apparitions and thought-transference: an examination of the evidence for telepathy
Podmore, Frank
Apparitions; Telepathy
Later on, after various trials had been made with little success with
letters, playing cards, and diagrams, a series of experiments was made
in the transference of mental pictures. There were in all 108 trials,
with 5 percipients--Miss B., P., and T., and two men, Whybrew and
Major, who had been subjects of an itinerant lecturer on Hypnotism.
The method of experiment was as follows:--A subject for a picture was
written down by Mrs. Sidgwick or Miss Johnson and handed to Mr. Smith,
who then summoned up a mental representation of the subject suggested,
which he tried to transfer to the percipient. Occasionally, to aid his
imagination, he drew on paper a rough sketch of the subject. During the
experiment Mr. Smith was sometimes close to the percipient, sometimes
behind a screen, sometimes in another room.
When in the same room it was occasionally necessary for Mr. Smith, in
order to keep alive the percipient's interest and attention, to say a
few words to him from time to time. These remarks were always recorded.
In the earlier experiments the percipient's eyes were open, and he was
given a white card or a crystal to look at; and he appears to have seen
the pictures as if projected on these objects. In the later trials the
percipient's eyes were closed, but this change in the conditions does
not appear in any way to have affected the vividness of the impressions.
Successful experiments were made with all five percipients, full
details of which will be found in the paper referred to.[38] It will
suffice here to quote a few illustrative cases of success, complete or
partial.
The first experiments were made on July 9th, 1890. Miss B. was the
percipient. I quote the account of the first two trials:--
No. 15.
The percipient, being in a hypnotic trance, had her eyes opened and
was given a card and told to look out for a picture which would
come on it.
The subject, chosen by Mrs. Sidgwick, was _a little boy with a
ball_. Mr. Smith sat close to Miss B., but neither spoke to her nor
touched her. Miss B. presently said: "A figure is coming--a little
boy." Mrs. Sidgwick asked what he had in his hand, and Miss B.
replied: "A round thing; a ball, I suppose."
For the next experiment Mr. Smith got behind a screen. The subject,
_a kitten in a jar_, was again set by Mrs. Sidgwick. Miss B. said:
"Something like an old cat--a cat--I think it's a cat." Mrs.
Sidgwick: "What is the cat doing?" Miss B. (doubtfully): "Sitting
down." Mrs. Sidgwick: "Is there anything else but a cat?" Miss B.:
"No; only scratches about."
In all 21 experiments of the kind were tried with Miss B., of which
8, including the two above recorded, may be classed as more or less
successful.
The following experiments were made with P. on November 5th, 1890.
The notes of these cases were taken by Miss Johnson, who was herself
ignorant of the subject, which was chosen by Mrs. Sidgwick.
The first experiment on this day was a failure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account