Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
The most considerable English public monument built just after the mid
century, the Leeds Town Hall of 1855-9, is by Cuthbert Brodrick (Plate
78A). That Brodrick was an architect markedly French in his leanings has
already been noted in describing his Leeds Corn Exchange, which is later
in date but earlier in style than his Town Hall (see Chapter 4). But
this major early work, for which Brodrick won the commission in a
competition in 1853, is not easily pigeon-holed stylistically. The great
hall inside derives quite directly from Elmes’s in Liverpool, designed
almost a quarter of a century earlier, though not opened until 1856. The
exterior recalls in its grandiose scale the English Baroque of Vanbrugh
more than it does anything that had even been projected since the
megalomaniac French projects of the 1790s. The Leeds Town Hall is
certainly no longer Romantic Classical, no longer Early Victorian; yet
except for the rather clumsy originality of some of the detail and the
varied outline of the tower—a late emendation of the original project of
1853—it is hard to say how or why it is so definitely High Victorian,
and rather a masterpiece of the High Victorian at that. Wallot in Berlin
in the eighties approached Brodrick’s mode of design in the Reichstag
but had little of his command of scale or his almost Romantic Classical
control of mass.
When Brodrick designed his town hall very little was known in England of
Visconti’s project of 1852 for the New Louvre, and Lefuel had not yet
begun to elaborate the design. So vigorously individual an architect as
Brodrick was hardly likely, moreover, to find inspiration in the Hope
house of Dusillion or the Hardwicks’ Great Western Hotel. But the wave
of Second Empire influence arrived in England well before the Leeds Town
Hall was finished. When the English swarmed to Paris to visit the
International Exhibition of 1855 the character of the New Louvre became
generally known to architects and to the interested public. The Crimean
War in the mid fifties served, moreover, to bring English and French
officialdom into close contact. To English ministers and civil servants,
even more than to architects and ordinary citizens, the existing
governmental accommodations in Whitehall contrasted most unfavourably
with those Napoleon III was providing in the New Louvre. When a
competition was held in 1856-7 for a new Foreign Office and a new War
Office to be built in Whitehall, it is not surprising that most of those
entrants who were not convinced Gothicists should have modelled their
projects more or less on the work of Visconti and Lefuel.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account