Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuriesHitchcock, Henry-Russell
History
Architecture : $b nineteenth and twentieth centuries
Hitchcock, Henry-Russell
Architecture, Modern -- 19th century; Architecture, Modern -- 20th century
Potter and Wight were both young men. Established Gothic Revivalists in
America did not swing over as rapidly as in England from the Early
Victorian to the High. Upjohn, Potter’s master, was no Butterfield;
Renwick when designing St Patrick’s Cathedral in New York in 1859
followed contemporary Continental rather than English models, as has
been noted, presumably because his clients were Catholics.
At best the sort of High Church Anglican patronage which sponsored
Butterfield’s and Street’s innovations in England was relatively much
less important in the United States—or Canada and Australia, for that
matter. Enthusiasm for the High Victorian Gothic, although widespread in
the later sixties and early seventies, was rarely exclusive as is
evidenced by the disparate interests and activities of the members of
the prominent and successful firm of Ware & Van Brunt. It has already
been noted that when William Robert Ware founded in 1865 the first
American architectural school at the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology in Boston, he based its instruction on that of the Paris
École des Beaux-Arts.[238] His partner Henry Van Brunt (1832-1903) was
one of the first to follow Richardson’s lead away from the High
Victorian Gothic in the seventies. So little were either of them
dyed-in-the-wool Gothicists in these decades.[239]
However, Ware & Van Brunt designed and built in Cambridge, Mass., one of
the largest and most conspicuous of mature High Victorian Gothic
edifices in America, Memorial Hall[240] at Harvard College, first
projected in the late sixties and erected in 1870-8. This somewhat
cathedral-like edifice has walls of red brick liberally lashed with
black and a massive central tower now denuded by fire of its high roof
(Plate 95A). The manner is more than a little Butterfieldian, but the
quality is not even up to G. G. Scott.
Before Memorial Hall was designed, a competition held in 1865 for the
First Church (Unitarian) in Boston in the new Back Bay residential
district had brought out a variety of rather feeble attempts by Boston
architects to follow the High Victorian Gothic line. The winning design
of Ware & Van Brunt, executed in 1865-7, while not of the wilder Low
Church order of Teulon’s or Keeling’s London work of these years, is
hardly comparable to Street’s or Butterfield’s, much less to the
contemporary production of younger architects such as Brooks, Bodley, or
Shaw. Its best feature is the material, the richly mottled and textured
local Puddingstone from nearby Roxbury.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account