Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and DarwinBall, W. P. (William Platt)
Philosophy
Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and Darwin
Ball, W. P. (William Platt)
Heredity; Variation (Biology)
[59] It is not claimed that the imperfect foot was on the same side of
the body as in the parent, and where parents had lost _all_ the toes of
a foot, or the whole foot, the few offspring affected usually had lost
only two toes out of the three, or only a part of one or two or three
toes. Sometimes the offspring had toes missing on _both_ hind feet,
although the parent was only affected in _one_. _One_ diseased ear and
eye in the parent was "generally" or "always" succeeded by _two_ equally
affected ears and eyes in the offspring (cf. _Pop. Science Monthly_, New
York, xi. 334). The important law of inheritance at corresponding
periods was also set aside. Gangrene or inflammation commenced in both
ears and both eyes soon after birth (pointing possibly to infection of
some kind); the epileptic period commenced "perhaps two months or more
after birth," while the loss of toes had occurred before birth. In no
case, as Weismann points out, is the original mutilation of the nervous
system ever transmitted. Even where an extirpated ganglion was never
regenerated in the parent, the offspring always regained the part in an
apparently perfect condition. On the whole the conflicting results ought
to be as puzzling to those who may attribute them to a universal
tendency to inherit the exact condition of parents as they are to those
who, like myself, are sceptical as to the existence of such a law or
tendency.
[60] The various results need to be fully and impartially recorded, and
they should also be well tested and confirmed in proportion as they
appear improbable and contrary to general experience. Professor Romanes
has been carrying out the necessary experiments for some time past.
[61] Natural History Museum, central hall, third recess on the left.
[62] _Traite de l'Heredite_, ii. 489; _Variation of Animals and Plants
under Domestication_, i. 469. If injuries are inherited, why has the
repeated rupture of the hymen produced no inherited effect?
[63] Compare the three cases of crooked fingers given in _Variation of
Animals and Plants under Domestication_, ii. 55, 240.
[64] _Ibid._, i. 460. Thus, where two brothers married two sisters all
the seven children were perfect albinos, although none of the parents or
their relatives were albinos. In another case the nine children of two
sound parents were all born blind (ii. 322).
[65] See pp. 179-182, _Evolution and Disease_, by J. Bland Sutton, to
whom and to our mutual friend Dr. D. Thurston I am indebted for
information on various points.
[66] _Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication_, ii. 290; i.
454.
MISCELLANEOUS CONSIDERATIONS.
TRUE RELATION OF PARENTS AND OFFSPRING.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account