Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and DarwinBall, W. P. (William Platt)
Philosophy
Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and Darwin
Ball, W. P. (William Platt)
Heredity; Variation (Biology)
wonderful perfection and at a remarkably early date. It transmits new
paces in horses in a single generation, but fails to perpetuate the
songs of birds. It modifies offspring like parents, and yet allows the
formation of two reproductive types in plants, and of two or more types
widely different from the parents in some of the higher insects. It is
said to be indispensable for the co-ordinated development of man and the
giraffe and the elk, but appears to be unnecessary for the evolution and
the maintenance of wonderful structures and habits and instincts in a
thousand species of ants and bees and termites. It is the only possible
means of complex evolution and adaptation of co-operative parts, and yet
in Mr. Spencer's most representative case it renders such important
parts as teeth and jaws unsuited for each other, and is said to ruin the
teeth by the consequent overcrowding and decay. It survives amidst a
general "lack of recognised evidence," and only seems to act usefully
and healthily and regularly in quarters where it can least easily be
distinguished from other more powerful and demonstrable factors of
evolution. So little does it care to display its powers where they would
be easily verifiable as well as useful that practical breeders ignore
it. So slight is its independent power that it seems to allow natural
selection or sexual selection or artificial selection to modify
organisms in sheer defiance of its utmost opposition, just as readily as
they modify organisms in other directions with its utmost help. If it
partially perpetuates and extends the pecked-out indentations in the
motmot's tail feathers, it on the other hand fails to transmit the
slightest trace of mutilation in an almost infinite number of ordinary
cases, and even where the mutilation is repeated for a hundred
generations; and it apparently repairs rather than transmits the
ordinary and oft-repeated losses caused by plucking hair, down and
feathers, and the wear and tear of claws, teeth, hoofs and skin.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account