Art Principles with Special Reference to Painting: Together with Notes on the Illusions Produced by the PainterGovett, Ernest
Philosophy
Art Principles with Special Reference to Painting: Together with Notes on the Illusions Produced by the Painter
Govett, Ernest
Art; Painting
It is curious that among the countless pictures of the Annunciation, in
very few indeed has surprise been expressed in the countenance and
attitude of the Virgin, though it is impossible to imagine an incident
more properly calling for profound astonishment on the part of the
principal personage in a composition, even in the absence of startling
miraculous accessories such as that introduced by Rossetti. Probably the
reason for this is connected with the difficulty of expressing great
surprise unaccompanied with some other feeling, as pleasure, or sorrow,
or fear, but there does not seem to be any cause why an exalted joyful
excitement should not be exhibited. Mrs. Jameson thinks that the Virgin
should not appear startled, as She was "accustomed to the perpetual
ministry of Angels who daily and hourly attended on Her,"[a] but it is
questionable whether this can be properly assumed by the artist, and in
any case from the point of view of art, the action should correspond
with the nature of the event as it is generally understood. Of the few
masters who have indicated surprise in an Annunciation picture,
Tintoretto has gone the farthest. He shows the Virgin with Her lips
parted, and both hands held up, evidently with astonishment,[b] an
example followed by Paris Bordone.[c] Raphael in an early picture
represents Her holding up one hand, but the attitude might signify the
reception of an announcement of importance.[d] Perugino shows Her with
both hands raised, but otherwise She appears unconcerned.[e] A few other
artists, including Venusti and Foppa, and among modern men, Girodet,
adopt Raphael's method of composition. Rubens goes a step farther, and
represents the Virgin apparently standing back with surprise, though
this is only faintly suggested by the facial expression.[f]
[a] _Legends of the Madonna._
[b] Scuolo di San Rocoo, Venice.
[c] Sienna Gallery.
[d] The Vatican.
[e] Santa Maria Nouvo, Perugia.
[f] Vienna Gallery.
INDEX OF SCULPTORS, PAINTERS, AND WORKS OF ART
NOTE.--The Schools to which the earlier Italian painters belonged are
given in brackets.
A
Adam, Franz, 1815-1886, German
--Bavarian Regiment before Orleans, 257
Aivasovsky, I. K., 1817-1900, Russian, 205
Albani, Francesco, 1578-1660, Italian, 163
--Toilet of Venus, 118
Albertinelli, Mariotto, 1467-1512, Italian [Florentine]
--The Salutation, 243
Alcamenes, fifth century B.C., Greek, 304
Altdorfer, A., 1480 (_c._)-1538, German
--The Nativity, 268
Aman, Jean, 1860-, French
--Sorbonne panels, 254
Ancher, Anna K., 1859-, Danish
--The Funeral, 189
Andreani, A., 1540-1623, Italian, 257
Angelico, Fra (Giovanni da Fiesole), 1387-1455,
Italian [Florentine], 17, 101
Antico (Pier Giacomo Ilario), worked late 15th and early 16th century,
Italian, 326
Antonella da Messina, 1421 (_c._)-1493, Italian [Venetian]
--Crucifixion, 243
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account