Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
When the witness is not isolated, but is a member of a group, the
defects we have before noted, due to the creative imagination, are
likely to be accentuated. The event will have been discussed and a
uniform version gradually prepared. It is almost impossible, from
the unanimous testimony of a number of witnesses who have been in
consultation, to extract the original perceptions. The phenomenon of
_mimétisme testimonial_ makes its appearance, and may assume
abnormal dimensions. A kind of collective hysteria may be induced, and
there can be little doubt that some of the collective denunciations of
witches which took place in the Middle Ages were manifestations of this
form of mimicry.
Such are some of the results that have been reached by the modern
investigations of the value of human testimony. They tell us little
we did not know before, for mankind has had an immense experience of
human testimony; but they make our knowledge more precise and enable us
to see what kinds of testimony are most open to suspicion. The effect
of these researches on judicial procedure should be considerable, and
their influence on the study of history not less marked. On this latter
subject their influence can only be indirect, and in the direction,
probably, of throwing still more doubt on the accuracy of historical
records. The “credibility” of a witness still remains a vague quantity,
but the chances are that it is something less than the value hitherto
assigned to it. The investigation can claim no such precise results
as those enunciated by Craig in 1699 in his _Theologiæ Christianæ
Principia mathematica_, where, after proving that the suspicions of
any history vary in the duplicate ratio of the times taken from the
beginning of the history, he shows that faith in the Gospel, so far as
it depended on oral tradition, expired about the year 880, and, so far
as it depended on written tradition, would expire in the year 3150. The
new investigations of the value of human testimony start from humbler,
but surer, foundations.
_Printed in Great Britain by_ Butler & Tanner, _Frome and
London_
=TRANSCRIBER’S NOTES=
Simple typographical errors have been silently corrected; unbalanced
quotation marks were remedied when the change was obvious, and
otherwise left unbalanced.
Punctuation, hyphenation, and spelling were made consistent when a
predominant preference was found in the original book; otherwise they
were not changed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account