Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
Saccheri was a Jesuit, and it was in 1690, while he was teaching
grammar in Milan, that he first studied the _Elements_ of Euclid.
He was a man of very great acumen, and when he, in turn, succumbed to
the spell of the parallel postulate, he brought to bear on it a more
subtle and rigorous logic than had yet been applied to it. Thirty-six
years before he published his treatise on Euclid he had published a
book on logic which gives him a high place as a logician. In it he
is particularly concerned with investigating the compatibility of
different assumptions or postulates. His method was to determine
whether a member of a group of postulates is independent of the others
by finding a particular case in which the postulate in question is not
true while all the others remain true. If such a case can be found, it
is obvious that the postulate in question cannot be deduced from the
others, else it would be true whenever they were true. This was the
method he applied to the parallel postulate of Euclid. He showed that
the parallel postulate is equivalent to saying that the three interior
angles of a triangle are equal to two right angles. He proceeds,
therefore, in accordance with his method, to develop the consequences
of supposing them less than, or greater than, two right angles. In
the latter case he succeeds in showing that we are led to impossible
conclusions, since he assumed, as everybody assumed for more than a
century after, that the straight line is of infinite length. But in the
former case, the hypothesis that the interior angles of a triangle are
together less than two right angles, Saccheri, although he struggled
very hard, did not succeed in falling into contradictions. He does not
seem to have had the boldness necessary completely to trust his own
logic, but the fact remains that, accepting the rest of Euclid’s axioms
and denying the parallel axiom, he developed a logically consistent
geometry.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account