Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
That our thinking, and with it our feeling, is largely conditioned
by assumptions which have no logical necessity, is a commonplace of
philosophy, and is indeed apparent to the slightest introspection.
Characteristic of any age is a body of beliefs, resting on more or less
good evidence, and a group of feelings associated with those beliefs.
The German language, so rich in indefinite but valuable general terms,
afforded the word _Zeitgeist_ for this complex, a word we have
directly translated into the Spirit of the Age. The name is a good
one; it indicates that we are dealing with something which is widely
diffused and also subject to change. It is subject to change, but it
plays a dominating rôle in the age to which it belongs. The Spirit of
the Age is something that practically all the intellectual life of the
age has in common. It is not manifested only in philosophical treatises
or in works of art; it is often manifested even more strikingly in
statesmen’s speeches and a country’s domestic and foreign policy. It is
a kind of intellectual and emotional atmosphere of which everybody is
aware, but which probably nobody could define. We see, however, that
a very important part of it consists of a sense of probability, of a
tendency to accept certain kinds of explanation and to reject others.
For the last few decades, at any rate, Science has been the chief
factor in forming this omnipresent sense of probability. As a matter
of fact, it is probable that the influence of Science in forming
the Spirit of the Age can be traced a very long way back, as far
back as Copernicus. Not that we assert the existence of a close
connection between the Science and the other intellectual activities
of Copernicus’s own age. The influence of which we speak is likely to
manifest itself gradually; in particular, it may take a long time to
affect the arts. And by the time it has percolated so far its origin
may be forgotten; it may appear as a subconscious rather than as a
conscious group of assumptions. By the time a scientific discovery
becomes part of the mental furniture of an age, many of what were
originally its possible implications will have become an integral part
of it. The original discovery will then be merely the nucleus of a rich
intellectual and, possibly, emotional complex, of which the parts are
no longer envisaged separately. The work of Newton, for example, and
the great body of exact investigations he made possible, influenced the
outlook of the nineteenth century chiefly in the direction of making
determinism plausible. Such lecturers as Tyndall could confidently
appeal to this mental predisposition on the part of their audience,
although they had no need to postulate any direct acquaintance with the
work of Newton and of his successors. The fact that Newton successfully
formulated exact laws for the description of natural phenomena is
the important aspect of his work from our present point of view. The
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account