Astronomical Curiosities: Facts and FallaciesGore, J. Ellard (John Ellard)
Science
Astronomical Curiosities: Facts and Fallacies
Gore, J. Ellard (John Ellard)
Astronomy -- Miscellanea; Solar system -- Miscellanea
The famous group of the Pleiades is well known; but there is great
difficulty in understanding Al-Sufi's description of the cluster. He says,
"The 29th star (of Taurus) is the more northern of the anterior side of
the Pleiades themselves, and the 30th is the southern of the same side;
the 31st is the following vertex of the Pleiades, and is in the more
narrow part. The 32nd is situated outside the northern side. Among these
stars, the 32nd is of the 4th magnitude, the others of the 5th." Now, it
is very difficult or impossible to identify these stars with the stars in
the Pleiades as they are at present. The brightest of all, Alcyone (η
Tauri), now about 3rd magnitude, does not seem to be mentioned at all by
Al-Sufi! as he says distinctly that "the brightest star" (No 32 of Taurus)
is "outside" the Pleiades "on the northern side." It seems impossible to
suppose that Al-Sufi could have overlooked Alcyone had it the same
brightness it has now. The 32nd star seems to have disappeared, or at
least diminished greatly in brightness, since the days of Al-Sufi. More
than four stars were, however, seen by Al-Sufi, for he adds, "It is true
that the stars of the Pleiades must exceed the four mentioned above, but
I limit myself to these four because they are very near each other and the
largest [that is, the brightest]; this is why I have mentioned them,
neglecting the others." A full examination of the whole question is given
by Flammarion in his interesting work _Les Étoiles_ (pp. 289-307), and I
must refer my readers to this investigation for further details.
According to Brown, Simonides of Keos (B.C. 556-467) says, "Atlas was the
sire of seven daughters with violet locks, who are called the heavenly
_Peleiades_."[405] The name is by some supposed to be derived from the
Greek πλειων, full. The Old Testament word _Kimah_ (Job ix. 9 and xxviii.
31) and Amos (v. 8) is derived from the Assyrian _Kimta_, a "family."
Aratus describes the Pleiades in the following lines:--
"Near his[406] left thigh together sweep along
The flock of Clusterers. Not a mighty span
Holds all, and they themselves are dim to see,
And seven paths aloft men say they take,
Yet six alone are viewed by mortal eye.
These seven are called by name Alkyonî
Kelainî, Meropî and Steropî
Taygetî, Elecktrî, Maia queen.
They thus together small and faint roll on
Yet notable at morn and eve through Zeus."[407]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account