In this great Epic nothing is more obvious than the terror the Greeks
felt when they first faced the Persians. The numbers arrayed against
them were overwhelming, their despondency was justifiable. It required
no little courage from a historian to tell the awkward truth--that
Herodotus did tell it is no small testimony to his veracity. Yet only
a little experience was needed to convince the Greeks that they were
superior on both land and sea. Once the lesson was learned, they never
forgot it. Mycale is the proof that they remembered it well. This
same consciousness of superiority animated two other Greek armies, one
deserted in the middle of Asia Minor, yet led unmolested by Xenophon
through a hostile country to the shores of the Black Sea--the other
commanded by Alexander the Great who planted Greek civilisation over
every part of his conquests, from the coast to the very gates of Persia
itself.
Modern history seems to have lost all powers of interesting its readers.
It is as dull as political economy; it suspects a stylist, questions
the accuracy of its authorities, tends to minimise personal influence
on events, specialises on a narrow period, emphasises constitutional
development, insists on the "economic interpretation" of an age and
at times seems quite unable to manage with skill the vast stores
of knowledge on which it draws. To it Herodotus is often a butt for
ridicule; his credulity, inability to distinguish true causes, belief
in divine influences, love of anecdote and chronological vagueness are
serious blemishes. But to us Herodotus is literature; we believe that
he himself laughs slyly at some of the anecdotes he has rendered more
piquant by a pretended credulity; this quick-witted Greek would find
it paid him to assume innocence in order to get his informers (like his
critics) to go on talking. Like Froissart, Joinville, de Comines and
perhaps even like Macaulay he wishes to write what will charm as well as
what will instruct.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account