Of all the orators of the ancient world none is more suitable for modern
use than Demosthenes. It is true that he is guilty of gross bad taste in
some of his speeches--but rarely in a parliamentary oration. Cicero is
too verbose and often insincere. Demosthenes is as a rule short, terse
and forcible. It is the undoubted justice of his cause which gives him
his lofty and noble style. He lacks the gentler touch of humour--but a
man cannot jest when he sees servitude before the country he loves.
With a few necessary alterations a speech of Demosthenes could easily
be delivered to-day, and it would be successful. Even Philip is said to
have admitted that he would have voted for him after hearing him, and
Aeschines after winning applause for declaiming part of Demosthenes'
speech told his audience that they ought to have heard the beast.
Yet all this splendid eloquence seems to have been wasted. The orator
could see much that was dark to his contemporaries, and spoke prophecies
true though vain. But the greatest thing of all was concealed from his
view. The inevitable day had dawned for the genuinely Greek type of
city. It was brilliant but it was a source of eternal divisions in a
world which had to be unified to be of any service. Its absurd factions
and petty leagues were really a hindrance to political stability.
Further, the essential vices of democracy cried aloud for a stern
master, and found him. Treason, bribery, appeals to an unqualified
voting class, theft of rich men's property under legal forms, free seats
in the theatre, belittlement of a great empire, pacifism, love of every
state but the right one--these are the open sores of popular control.
For such a society only one choice is possible; it needs discipline
either of national service or national extinction. Its crazy cranks will
not disappear otherwise. Modern political life is democratic; those who
imagine that the voice of the majority is the voice of Heaven should
produce reasons for their belief. They will find it difficult to hold
such a view if they will patiently consider the hard facts of history
and the unceasing warnings of Demosthenes.
* * * * *
No account of Greek literature would be complete without a mention of
the influence which has revolutionised human thought. It is a strange
coincidence that Aristotle was born and died in the same years as
Demosthenes. His native town was Stagira; he trained Alexander the
Great, presided over the very famous Peripatetic School at Athens for
thirteen years and found time to investigate practically every subject
of which an ancient Greek could be expected to have any knowledge.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account