Autobiography of Charles Clinton Nourse: Prepared for use of Members of the FamilyNourse, Charles Clinton
History
Autobiography of Charles Clinton Nourse: Prepared for use of Members of the Family
Nourse, Charles Clinton
Iowa -- Politics and government; Lawyers -- Iowa -- Biography; Nourse, Charles Clinton, 1829-
I have now answered very fully all of the inquiries in your letter
save, perhaps, the last, and that is as to the relation and effect
of the present suit to the cause of prohibition in Iowa. Permit me
to say to you, and through you to the true friends of prohibition
in this state, that we have now upon our statute books a most
excellent law, that is every day gaining favor with the people, and
that has survived all open warfare upon it. In my humble judgment
the most we now have to fear is not the open opposition of its
enemies, but the follies and indiscretions of its friends. As I
have already conclusively shown in this communication, we procured
the enactment of this law by assuring the people of this state that
we did not intend to interfere with the manufacture of alcohol or
intoxicating liquors for medicinal or mechanical purposes, nor as
an article of commerce for export. The question is, have we
anything to gain by duplicity and insincerity, and by now claiming
for this law what we did not claim for it when we procured its
enactment by the general assembly? Above all things, have we, as
prohibitionists, anything to gain by entering into an alliance with
the distillers of other states who are making war upon a productive
industry in our own state, for the sole purpose of promoting their
own pecuniary interests in destroying competition in their
business? Have we anything to gain by turning aside from the great
work that we have undertaken of destroying the saloon as a place of
resort where our young men are taught the habit of intoxication,
and engaging in the Utopian scheme of regulating the supply of
alcohol in the markets of the world, the use of which it is
impossible for us to control after it passes beyond the
jurisdiction of our laws?
There is another very grave and important question that the true
friends of prohibition in Iowa should stop to consider. The courts
of the United States have more than intimated that if the
prohibitory law of Iowa does in fact destroy the value of property
built for a use which was lawful at the time of its erection, that
such a law is a violation of the constitution of the United States,
unless it also makes provision for compensation to the owner.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account