Autobiography of Charles Clinton Nourse: Prepared for use of Members of the FamilyNourse, Charles Clinton
History
Autobiography of Charles Clinton Nourse: Prepared for use of Members of the Family
Nourse, Charles Clinton
Iowa -- Politics and government; Lawyers -- Iowa -- Biography; Nourse, Charles Clinton, 1829-
As soon as this became known to the Des Moines _Register_, its editors
commenced a series of abusive articles against me, containing
misrepresentations and insinuations, and for some reasons best known to
the editors of that paper and of which I am not advised, they became
very active in trying to promote the success of this prosecution
against the distillery and to destroy the same. These articles of the
State _Register_ created, of course, quite an inquiry among the friends
of prohibition in the state, and they wrote a number of letters to Mrs.
A. E. McMurray, secretary of the State Temperance League, making
inquiry in regard to the matter of my employment. She accordingly wrote
a letter to me upon the subject and I answered the same very fully,
giving a history of the whole controversy, and particularly the motives
of the men that were trying to destroy Kidd and his enterprise. Though
the letter is somewhat in detail, yet, as it is a complete answer to
all of the criticisms that have been made of my professional conduct in
this matter, I give it here in full:
DES MOINES, IOWA, MARCH 19, 1887.
Mrs. E. A. McMurray, Secretary of Iowa State Temperance Alliance:
I have your communication of the 17th inst., and appreciating the
motives that have prompted it, I take pleasure in responding to
your inquiries.
The case of I. E. Pearson and S. J. Loughran against John S. Kidd,
now pending upon appeal in the supreme court of the state, and in
which I have been retained for the defendant, involves only the
question as to the right of the defendant to manufacture alcohol in
this state, under the permit granted him by the board of
supervisors of Polk county, for the purpose of export. There is no
pretense that Mr. Kidd, since the taking effect of our present
statute, has ever sold any intoxicating liquors, or alcohol, within
the state of Iowa, for any purpose whatever. The only evidence
offered to sustain the petition is contained in the official
reports of Mr. Kidd to the auditor of the county, by which it
appears that he has manufactured alcohol and shipped it out of the
state. The article manufactured by Mr. Kidd and put upon the market
is not itself a beverage, and is not and cannot be used as such in
the form in which he has produced and sold it. The case was first
tried in the circuit court of Polk county, before Judges Given and
Henderson, upon an application for a preliminary injunction. In
December last those two judges delivered an opinion in the case,
deciding that Mr. Kidd had not in any manner violated the
prohibitory law, and they refused an injunction. At the present
term of the district court Judge Conrad, our newly-elected district
judge, put a different construction upon the law and held, that by
the amendment made to the prohibitory law by the legislation of
1884 it was unlawful to manufacture alcohol in the state for
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account