The history of religious controversy would be much simpler if all
adopted Barnum’s view, but his assumptions are rather large, and his
proofs are childishly vague. If he had anything but an _a priori_
faith, there was ample opportunity within the scope of his book to
announce it, and by neglecting to particularize some of the evidences
of Christian preëminence, he leaves his own dear faith wide open to
attack with his own thunder. The religious section of _The Humbugs of
the World_ suggests the conclusion that Barnum’s theological philosophy
was comparable to the conviction of the soldier who believed that every
one was out of step except himself.
The nearest Barnum allowed himself to approach criticism of his own
gods was a paragraph of condemnation of the long and “windy prayers” of
young, inexperienced clergymen, which he likened in mild and forgiving
terms to the prayer-mills of the heathens. There is no recognition,
however, of a possibility that Mohammedans, Buddhists, and followers
of Confucius may have real faiths as well as the humbugs incidental
to those faiths. Christianity’s humbugs he ignored altogether, except
in the matter of ordeals practised in faraway medieval days, and he
pointed out their absurdities only to prove “how much more preferable
is our American principle of separation in all matters of State and
Church.” Even this criticism was omitted in the English edition of
_The Humbugs of the World_. Barnum’s whole nationalist theology and
Christian philosophy can be narrowed down to a simple assertion, to the
effect that we, the Americans, are the greatest members of a Christian
world. He never said this in so many words, for he had too many friends
in England and France, but there was no necessity for regarding the
feelings of Mohammedans or Chinese, for after all were not these
peoples merely subjects for exhibition to a curious Christian world?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account