Bedouins: $b Mary Garden, Debussy, Chopin or the circus, Botticelli, Poe, Brahmsody, Anatole France, Mirbeau, Caruso on wheels, Calico cats, The artistic temperament; Idols and ambergris, with The supreme sin, Grindstones, A masque of music, and The vision malefic; with various portraits of Mary Garden in operatic costumeHuneker, James
History
Bedouins: $b Mary Garden, Debussy, Chopin or the circus, Botticelli, Poe, Brahmsody, Anatole France, Mirbeau, Caruso on wheels, Calico cats, The artistic temperament; Idols and ambergris, with The supreme sin, Grindstones, A masque of music, and The vision malefic; with various portraits of Mary Garden in operatic costume
Huneker, James
Garden, Mary, 1874-1967; Music -- History and criticism; Sopranos (Singers)
Sing and grow voiceless! Why not? We know of a dozen methods that
are guaranteed to ruin even a Rose Ponselle vocal equipment in
thirty lessons by mail, better known as absent treatment. We have
had over forty years’ experience in the fair land of song, a scarred
battle-field strewn with the shards and wrecks of beautiful voices
and high hopes. In no sphere of music are there so many sharks,
cormorants, swindlers, humbugs, criminals, as in the ranks of vocal
teaching--so-called. The hard-earned, carefully saved money of parents
is extorted from victims, who usually return home with health impaired,
voices gone, even worse. It is pitiful. It is cruel. What are you going
to do about it? The profession of medicine is protected. Why not music?
Malpractice is swiftly punished. Why not lock up the rascals who ruin
a voice and get money under false pretenses? No, chewing gum in public
is of far more importance to people; now a national neurosis, it will
soon be elevated to the dignity of a Fine Art. If we had our way we
should drive every one of these vocal parasites who infest the temple
of music into the swamp of public odium.
Now, having worked off my chronic bad humor, let us look at the
matter through the spectacles of the absurd. There is a comic
side to everything, from a volcano to a prohibitionist. The fake
singing-teachers are as funny as their fakery is pernicious.
I am reminded of all the pamphlets from How to be Happy Though
Divorced, How to Starve and Grow Fat when I read the pompous
pronouncements of certain Voice Builders. I confess that I am not an
expert in vocal hygiene, but I have heard all the great men and women
for the past half-century who have made this drab, dreary planet worth
living on with their beautiful voices. And that is a brevet of taste.
Standards. Without standards we critically perish, says, in effect,
Mr. Brownell. I also confess that I don’t know a resonator from a
refrigerator, or the difference between a lynx and a larynx. Both
growl, I believe, if you rub them the wrong way. I have not the science
of W. J. Henderson or Holbrook Curtis. But I do know when a singer
slathers her phrases or sings above or below pitch--and there are more
who sing sharp than you think. The main thing is that I criticise by
ear, not with a laryngoscope or a mirror to peep at the breath-control.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account