But the similarity consists not less in the ostensible grounds for
revolt, than in the identity of the actual instruments and agents.
In Belgium, as in Ireland, they were the uneducated and bigotted
mob, inflamed by the half-educated press, and led on by a propaganda
of priests and a crowd of unsuccessful and hungry lawyers. In both
countries, too, the leaders of the movement, whatever may have been
their real and secret sentiments, ostensibly professed to seek merely
a redress of grievances, and to start with alarm at the idea of
_separation_; their only desire being a _federative union_ under the
same crown, but with a distinct administration. The Belgian, however,
soon felt that he wanted a power, which there is but little reason
to ascribe to the Irishman of saying “thus far shalt thou go, and
no farther,” and the stimulants applied to the versatile vanity of
the people, soon rendered them impatient of any proposition short of
actual independence. An unfortunate phrase in the treaty of Paris
that Belgium was to be to Holland “as an accession of territory,” was
construed into a national indignity, notwithstanding the expression
of perfect equality and “fusion” which pervaded every other passage
of the document, and the cry of “_a nation no longer a province_”
became forthwith the aspiration of every discontented coterie. That
distinction they have, at length, attained, and enjoy the barren
eminence of a throne, but unfortunately without either the power, the
wealth, or the influence as an European state, that are essential to
give it dignity and stability.
There are, however, some points of marked distinction between the
two cases, inasmuch as whilst the Irish sufferers clamour _for_
assimilation to England, those in Belgium flew to arms _against_
assimilation with Holland; and, besides the Belgian repealer pursued
his object of separation notwithstanding the admitted prosperity of his
country, whilst the Irish one, less barefaced, tries eagerly to invent
a case of distress in order to justify his treason. Above all, there
is this happy difference, that whilst in Belgium the repeal has been
achieved at the expense of national prosperity, Ireland has still the
opportunity to reflect and to be warned by her lamentable example.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account