Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction TypeHoch, August
Science
Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
Hoch, August
Manic-depressive illness; Stupor
_December 15:_ Quiet as a rule, then for a time at the
door, pulling at it and with whining voice but affectlessly
saying “Give me the key--I want to go to the river--you
can’t keep me from Heaven--it is either Heaven or the
river, give me the keys, give me the keys, open the door,”
“The niggers are taking possession.” To the physician to
whom she had claimed to be married, often repeats “You
don’t belong to me, I don’t belong to you.” (What about the
niggers?) “A band of niggers, that is all they are.” (Are
the nurses niggers?) “That is all they are.” Asked about
her people, she says “They are in Heaven.” (Where are you?)
“I am in Heaven” (without change of expression). Again,
when asked where her people are, says “At home.” Then she
went willingly back to bed and was quiet. In the afternoon
she again went to the door and tried to get out. When
questioned, she said “I don’t want to be an animal,”
“Everybody is making an animal of me” (pointing to an
animal picture). Then again, while trying the door, repeats
in the same affectless manner that she wants to go “to the
river,” “to the bottom of the river,” “to Heaven to see my
mother.” This last was said in a whining tone, with some
tears. She kept turning the knob, tried to get the keys,
and struggled impulsively when prevented.
_December 23:_ Though quiet on the whole, when a visitor
came yesterday, she ran after this woman saying “I want my
generations,” and clung to her, and to-day at intervals
keeps talking about wanting to see her generations but is
often quiet. (Retrospectively she said she wanted to see
all her ancestors from the beginning of time.)
_December 27:_ Of late often talks affectlessly about
wanting to die or wanting to go to Heaven, struggling
impulsively to get medicine away from the nurses, asking
for poison, trying to drink her own urine, or even the
fluid in the bed pan after she had been given an enema, all
evidently with suicidal intent.
_December 28:_ Still constant, impulsive and apparently
affectless attempts at suicide, tries to get medicine away
from nurses, to get the fire extinguisher bottles, a bottle
of ink, etc., struggling when prevented.
But when examined quiet, even smiles at a joke. When
questioned, denies feeling either worried or depressed. She
said she wanted to go home. She gave poor attention to the
questions. Later she threw a wet sheet over a patient and
laughed (this is rare). Later she slapped another patient.
Again she began to talk about wishing to go to the grave.
Calls Dr. M. “Uncle John.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account