Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction TypeHoch, August
Science
Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
Hoch, August
Manic-depressive illness; Stupor
Her condition then remained essentially the same for some
time. Then about six weeks after admission she became
somewhat less resistive, was frequently seen sitting up in
bed, moving her lips considerably (without speech) and
regarding the surroundings with a bright interested
expression and occasionally smiles. About this time she
began exposing herself and chewing her finger nails.
Four months after admission she was noted as being very
resistive and negativistic, allowing saliva to accumulate
in her mouth and making no attempt to keep the flies off
her. At the same time she would keep in her mouth food that
had been put there without chewing it.
Two months later she seemed to laugh occasionally when
other patients did so, but at the same time she showed a
cataleptic tendency and was quite mute.
Six months after admission she began to feed herself but
rather sloppily. When one would speak to her, she would
occasionally smile, but if shaken she would weep silently.
About this time she began to do a little work in the ward,
pushing a floor polisher.
For the next couple of months her condition was about the
same. She would stand around the ward, doing a little work
if urged, might even dance if forced to. She was
consistently mute. She was dirty but often decorated
herself. Rarely she was assaultive.
Then ten months after admission she one day suddenly
became talkative, distractible and emotional, laughing and
crying. There was with this, however, no open elation. Her
talk was obscene, at times flighty, at times definitely
scattered. All her habits were filthy.
This pseudomanic episode lasted for a couple of months, and
then she settled down to a fairly consistent deterioration
with indifference, silly laughter, occasional
assaultiveness, destructiveness and untidiness.
Nearly two years after admission she had another period of
excitement lasting about a couple of months. Shortly after
this she began to fail physically, and in November, 1913,
two years and five months after her admission, she died of
pulmonary tuberculosis.
In summary, then, we see that this patient exhibited symptoms of
dementia præcox from the outset of her stupor, with scattering, genital
sensations and incest ideas. The stupor symptoms gradually gave way to
the typical indifference, negativism, obscenity, filthiness and
inexplicable conduct of dementia præcox. At the beginning, however, the
condition was superficially similar to that of a benign stupor, it being
only on careful observation that other symptoms were noted.
CASE 21.--_Rose S._ Age: 23. Admitted to the Psychiatric
Institute April 5, 1905.
_F. H._ The mother was living, the father dead. Otherwise
no pertinent information was secured.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account