*Sainte-Beuve, C. A. _Portraits of the Eighteenth Century._ Tr. by K. P. Wormeley, with a critical introduction by E. Scherer. New York: 1905. I, 311-75. (The two essays on Franklin in _Causeries du lundi_ are "here put together," though with no important omissions from either. Brilliant portrait of the "most gracious, smiling, and persuasive utilitarian," one who assigned "no part to human imagination.") Seipp, Erika. _Benjamin Franklins Religion und Ethik._ Darmstadt: 1932. (Suggestive, though brief, view of Franklin's deism and utilitarianism. Attempts to see his thought in reference to various representative deists. This is not, however, a "source" study.) Shepherd, W. R. _History of Proprietary Government in Pennsylvania._ New York: 1896. (Franklin emerges as "a sort of tribune to the people," a "mighty Goliath," a "plague" in the eyes of the feudalistic rulers of Pennsylvania, "a huge fief." Author relatively unsympathetic to Franklin.) *Sherman, S. P. "Franklin and the Age of Enlightenment," in _Americans_. New York: 1922, pp. 28-62. (Penetrating survey and estimate.) Smith, William, D.D. _Eulogium on Benjamin Franklin._ Philadelphia: 1792. (One agrees with P. L. Ford, that this work "forms a somewhat amusing contrast to the savageness of the Doctor's earlier writings against Franklin." Bombastic in its rhetoric and eulogy.) Smythe, J. H., Jr., comp. _The Amazing Benjamin Franklin._ New York: 1929. (Anthology of brief, popular estimates. If individual notes are trivial, the collection illustrates Franklin's many-mindedness, a Renaissance versatility.) Sonneck, O. G. "Benjamin Franklin's Relation to Music," _Music_, XIX, 1-14 (Nov., 1900). Steell, Willis. _Benjamin Franklin of Paris, 1776-1785._ New York: 1928. (An undocumented, partly imaginative, popular account.) Stifler, J. M. _The Religion of Benjamin Franklin._ New York: 1925. (Popular survey. Warm appreciation of Franklin's _penchant_ for projects of a humanitarian sort.) Stuber, Henry. "Life of Franklin" [a biography meant as a continuation of Franklin's _Autobiography_], in _Columbian Magazine and Universal Asylum_, May, July, September, October, November, 1790, and February, March, May, June, 1791. *Thorpe, F. N., ed. _Benjamin Franklin and the University of Pennsylvania._ U. S. Bureau of Education, Circular of Information, No. 2 (1892). Washington: 1893. (See especially chapters I, II, written by Thorpe, which deal particularly with Franklin's ideas of self and formal education.) Titus, Rev. Anson. "Boston When Ben Franklin Was a Boy," _Proceedings of the Bostonian Society_, pp. 55-72 (1906). (Brief suggestive view of the climate of opinion with regard to inoculation, Newtonianism, and Lockian sensationalism.)