Birth control laws : $b shall we keep them, change them, or abolish themDennett, Mary Ware
History
Birth control laws : $b shall we keep them, change them, or abolish them
Dennett, Mary Ware
Birth control; Birth control -- Law and legislation -- United States
The people can get just what they want from Congress and the State
Legislatures regarding the birth control question, if they make
their wants known definitely enough. If they leave it wholly to the
relatively few citizens who take the trouble to go down to Washington
and worry bills through Congress, they may wake later to find that
misguided enthusiasm has done for this generation what Comstock did
for his generation—enacted laws which were well meant, but which have
worked ill. Some senator of our day may have to warn Congress as did
Senator Conkling in 1873, lest we “do something which when we come to
see it in print, will not be the thing we would have done if we had
understood it.” It is doubtful if any thoughtful members of Congress
or any clear-headed citizens could be proud if it should happen that
the laws affecting birth control were amended so as to create a special
privilege in access to knowledge instead of freedom for all; if they
established monopoly instead of equal opportunity; or if they created
paternalism instead of democracy. No one in later years would bless
Congress for passing another batch of unenforceable laws. And it is
safe to say also that American citizens would not bless any birth
control advocates who, after endless talk and the expenditure of time
and money which Congressional work requires, should persuade Congress
to leave the subject of birth control still mired in the obscenity laws
where Comstock (and Congress meekly acquiescing) placed it over half a
century ago.
Much water has gone under the bridge since birth control corrective
legislation was first proposed. Congressional inhibitions have
considerably lessened. The whole subject in press, pulpit, fiction and
private life is on a more wholesome plane than ever before. The time is
ripe to have that improvement reflected into sound legislative action.
Congress will just as willingly do the fine thing as the flimsy thing,
if the people demand it. Congress will help to take birth control out
of the laws, instead of putting it into further spurious laws, if the
people say so.
It is up to the public to let the birth control workers know what is
wanted, and for both the birth control workers and the public to let
Congress know what is wanted—and wanted with the best that is in
people’s minds and hearts, not what is dictated by their superficial
fears, their doubts and their shames.
Professor Raymond Pearl has said: “The cure for the defects of birth
control, paraphrasing the old remark about democracy, is more and
more democratic birth control.” And surely the cure for the defects
of legislation regarding birth control is more and more democratic
legislation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account