Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 60, No. 373, November 1846Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 60, No. 373, November 1846
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
I have, therefore, little opportunity of judging whether the characters
depicted by some of our later serialists, are exact copies from nature
or the reverse. I have, however, heard several young ladies declare them
to be extremely natural, though I confess to have been somewhat puzzled
as to their means of accurate information. But I may be allowed _en
passant_ to remark, that it seems difficult to imagine what kind of
pleasure can be derived from the description of a scene, which, if
actually contemplated by the reader, would inspire him with loathing and
disgust, or from conversations in which the brutal alternates with the
positive obscene. The fetid den of the Jew, the stinking cellar of the
thief, the squalid attic of the prostitute, are not haunts for honest
men, and the less that we know of them the better. Such places no doubt
exist--the more is the pity; but so do dunghills, and a hundred other
filthy things, which the imagination shudders at whenever they are
forced upon it,--for the man who willingly and deliberately dwells upon
such subjects, is, notwithstanding all pretext, in heart and soul a
nightman! Don't tell me about close painting after nature. Nature is
not always to be painted as she really is. Would you hang up such
paintings in your drawing-room? If not, why suffer them in print to lie
upon your drawing-room tables? What are Eugene Sue and his English
competitors, but coarser and more prurient Ostades?
Oh, but there is a moral in these things! No doubt of it. There is a
moral in all sin and misery, as there is in all virtue and happiness.
There is a moral every where, and the veriest bungler cannot fail to
seize it. But is that a reason why the minds of our sons and daughters
should be polluted by what is notoriously the nearest thing to contact
with absolute vice--namely, vivid and graphic descriptions of it by
writers of undenied ability? Did _Life in London_, or the exploits of
Tom, Jerry, and Logic, make the youth of the metropolis more staid, or
inspire them with a wholesome horror of dissipation? Did the memoirs of
Casanova ever reclaim a rake--the autobiography of David Haggart convert
an aspiring pickpocket--or the daring feats of Jack Sheppard arrest one
candidate for the gallows? These are the major cases; but look at the
minor ones. What are the favourite haunts of the heroes in even the most
blameless of our serials? Pot-houses--cigariums--green-rooms of
theatres--hells--spunging-houses--garrets--and the scullery! Nice and
improving all this--isn't it, Smith?--for the young and rising
generation! No need now for surreptitious works, entitled, "A Guide to
the Larks of London," or so forth, which used formerly to issue from the
virgin press of Holywell Street. Almost any serial will give hints
enough to an acute boy, if he wishes to gain an initiative knowledge of
subjects more especially beneath the cognisance of the police. They will
at least guide him to the door with the red lamp burning over it, and
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account