Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 67, No. 415, May, 1850Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 67, No. 415, May, 1850
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
To republish criticisms, especially such as relate to the works of
cotemporaries, is certainly a more delicate task. It is easy to comment
upon an author whose works have been long before the public, and
frequently and diligently scanned. High criticism may discover beauties
or detect faults which have escaped the notice of less keen and
scrutinising observers; but, in the aggregate, certainly in the majority
of cases, the broad opinion which has been expressed by others is
allowed to remain unchallenged. The influence of previous judgment
invariably sways the critic. None are rash enough to deny the genius of
Shakspeare; at the same time, nothing is more certain than that, were
another Shakspeare to arise amongst us at this moment, there would be no
kind of unanimity as to his deserts. In all ages and in all countries
this has been the rule. Personal spite, unacknowledged and possibly
unperceived envy, party difference of opinion, disparity of station,
prejudice of education—all these, in their turn, have passed, like so
many clouds, between the sun of living genius and the critics who
surveyed its orbit. Nor ought we to overlook the fact that, in many
instances, meteors have been mistaken for suns, and the eyes of the
critic been dazzled by a glare, to which his own willing imagination
lent at least one half its brilliancy. Therefore it is that contemporary
criticism, when republished in an abiding form, rarely satisfies the
expectation of the reader. His own judgment has been formed, apart from
the considerations and prejudices which are so apt to beset the critic;
and he conceives an unfavourable impression of the literary acuteness of
the writer, when he finds a gross discrepancy between the older and the
later estimate.
But far more trying to an author is the republication of political
essays, composed during the progress of great national events. This
branch of composition is peculiar to our own age, in which periodical
literature is so marked and eminent a feature. Pamphleteering is of
venerable date. Sir Thomas More, Milton, Marvell, Swift, and Defoe, were
all notable pamphleteers; but periodical writing, in the highest sense
of the term, is the invention of the present century. That great and
influential organs of public opinion, ranking among their contributors
the men of the highest intellect and the most laborious acquirements,
should have been established in our time, marks not only the development
of the influence of the press, but the importance of the events which
such men are imperatively summoned to discuss. It marks even more, for
it has established a power beyond the boundaries of the old
constitution, which, as it is used or misused, cannot fail to affect
materially the destinies of Great Britain.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account