Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 68, No 422, December 1850Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 68, No 422, December 1850
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"Sir James Anderson,--With the permission of the House, I think it
my duty to inform you, after the opening we have heard made by the
Attorney-General of the facts of the case, that you are not bound to
answer any question _which may tend to criminate yourself_." Doubtless,
Sir James Anderson expected nothing less, and had come to the House of
Lords perfectly at his ease. Therefore he came like a shadow, and so
departed. Thus "had he his entrance and his exit."
"_Attorney-General._--Of what profession are you?
"_A._--I am a physician.
"_Q._--Where do you live?
"_A._--New Burlington Street.
"_Q._--Are you acquainted with Captain Tuckett?
"_A._--I must decline answering that.
"_Q._--Were you on Wimbledon Common on the 12th September last?
"_A._--I must decline answering that also!
"_Q._--Were you on that day called in to attend any gentleman that was
wounded?
"_A._--I am sorry to decline that again!
"_Q._--Can you tell me where Captain Tuckett lives?
"_A._--I must decline answering the question!
"_Q._--Has he a house in London?
"_Sir William Follett._--He 'declines to answer the question.'
"_A._--I have already said that I decline answering the question.
"_Attorney-General._--Where did you last see Captain Tuckett?
"_Sir William Follett._--We [the counsel for the prisoner] have no
_right_, my Lords, to interfere in this case;[57] but, the witness
having several times declined to answer the question, I apprehend that
it is not regular for the Attorney-General, by circuitous questions,
to endeavour to get him to answer.
"_Attorney-General._--I have never pressed him in any question I have
put. [_To Sir James Anderson._]--Do you decline answering any question
whatever respecting Captain Tuckett?
"_A._--_Any_ question which may 'tend to criminate' myself.
"_Q._--And you consider that answering any question respecting Captain
Tuckett _may_ tend to criminate yourself?
"_A._--It is possible that it would.
"_Q._--And on that ground you decline?
"_A._--Yes.
"_Attorney-General_, [_to the House_.]--Then, unless your Lordships
wish to ask any question of the witness, he may withdraw.
"The witness was directed to withdraw."
Here, then, were four avenues through which light might have been
thrown on a transaction which was the subject of such solemn and
dignified inquiry by the most illustrious judicial assembly in the
world, carefully closed: Sir James Anderson, Captain Tuckett, Captain
Douglas, and Captain Wainwright. It will be further observed that Lord
Cardigan, in his frank avowal at the police station, had happened not
to mention the name of the gentleman whom he had fought and wounded--an
omission probably altogether accidental, for his Lordship seems to have
been in a humour of signal yet becoming and characteristic frankness.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account