Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 75, No. 462, April 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 75, No. 462, April 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
The next and last point which we shall notice is the representation of
minorities. We do not know to whom the credit of having invented this
notable scheme is really due. There are various claimants in the field.
Mr G. L. Craik, of Queen’s College, Belfast, asserts that he was the
original discoverer, having propounded a plan of this nature so early as
1836. Ingenious as the idea may be, it will hardly rank in importance
with the discovery of the steam-engine, nor do we think that its
originator is entitled to any exorbitant share of public gratitude or
applause. We shall give it as we find it in the _Review_.
_Source of Lord John Russell’s proposal to give members in certain cases
to minorities._—“The mode by which we propose to insure the constituent
minorities their fair share in the representation—_i. e._ to make the
majorities and minorities in the House of Commons correspond as nearly
as may be to majorities and minorities in the country, or in the
electoral bodies—is, to give (as now) to each elector as many votes as
there are members to be chosen, and to allow him to divide these votes
as he pleases among the candidates, _or to give them all to one_. But as
at present most places return two members, it is obvious that, under the
proposed arrangement, wherever the minority _exceeded one-third_ of the
total number of the electors, they would be able to return one member,
or to obtain _one-half_ the representation, which would be more than
their fair share, and would place them on an equality with the majority,
which would never do; while, if they _fell short of one-third_, they
would be, as now, virtually unrepresented and ignored. To obviate this,
it will be necessary so to arrange our electoral divisions, that as many
constituencies as possible should return _three_ members: one of these a
minority, if at all respectable, could always manage to secure.”—_Edin.
Review_, Oct. 1853, p. 622.
Here, at all events, is the notion about the representation of
majorities, and the establishment of as many constituencies as possible,
returning _three_ members. Lord John Russell’s method of working this,
is to restrict each elector to two votes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account