Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 75, No. 463, May, 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 75, No. 463, May, 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
order to gratify their sensual inclinations, as the poor to procure
food.
To call a man a liar is, in England, and in the European world
generally, the surest way to provoke anger; but such an epithet has but
little weight attached to it in China. This is partly owing to the fact
that “white lies” have there a recognised and reputable existence not
openly accorded to them elsewhere. In the eyes of a Chinese, as in the
code of the Jesuits, a lie in itself is not absolutely criminal, and it
may, on the contrary, be very meritorious. According to Confucius, a lie
told by a child to benefit a parent is deserving of praise; and a
Jeannie Deans, or the stern old father in Mr Warren’s _Now and Then_, so
far from being held models of religion, would be regarded, the one as a
stubborn fanatic, and the other as the most heartless and unnatural of
parents. But another, and, we suspect, a much more powerful cause of
this want of veracity among the Chinese, is their system of government.
Here, as throughout Asia generally, Despotism—or, in other words, an
Executive power from which there is no proper appeal—generates mendacity
in the people, as their sole refuge from irresponsible Power. Duplicity
is the resource to which Weakness naturally betakes itself; and it is
universally adopted wherever the decrees of Government officials are
felt to be unjust as well as unappealable. Everywhere the result is the
same; and in this, as in many other respects, a perfect parallel might
be drawn between those two vastest empires of modern times, the Chinese
and the Russian. In the latter empire, as in the former, the vastness of
the country and consequent impossibility of an efficient surveillance
over the host of officials, joined to the absence of municipal
institutions and a free press to act as checks upon local tyranny,
render it most difficult to detect or repress abuses of power on the
part of the Government officers. And the consequence in both countries
may be told in the words of Alison, applied to Russia:—“So universal is
the dread of authority, that it has moulded the national character.
Dissimulation is universal; and, like the Greeks under the Mussulman
yoke, the Russians have become perfect adepts in all the arts by which
talent eludes the force of authority, and astuteness escapes the
discoveries of power.” And we suspect we ought to add, in justice to the
Chinese, that this disposition has been impressed upon them, as upon the
Russians, by the invasion of the Tartar hordes, which in both countries
reduced the native race to subjection for three long centuries.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account