Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
Society is quite as intoxicating
as champagne; and it is impossible to write a book of this kind, without
recalling, to a considerable extent, the feeling of the bygone
excitement. We have no doubt that the printed narrative would seem
peculiarly sober, could we be favoured with a perusal of the actual
letters which Mrs Stowe despatched to America from the bewildering whirl
of London.
One thing, however, we have remarked with pain; and that is the
introduction by Mrs Stowe of an elaborate defence or explanation of what
were called the “Sutherland Clearings.” Her motive for doing so is quite
apparent; but we cannot help thinking that she has placed both herself,
and the noble family for whom she appears as an advocate, in a false and
disagreeable position, by putting forth statements of the accuracy of
which she had no means of judging. The transactions to which she refers
are of an old date; and they occurred in a district of which she has
absolutely no personal knowledge. She never was in Sutherland, or indeed
any other part of the Highlands, and therefore she was not entitled in
any way to deal with such a subject. That she was furnished with
materials for the purposes of publication seems more than probable: if
so, we cannot commend the prudence of those who took so singular a
method of refuting what may very possibly be calumny or
misrepresentation. With the merits of the case we have nothing to do,
nor shall we express any opinion upon them; but it does seem to us a
most extraordinary circumstance that Mrs Stowe should have been induced
to put forth a long, elaborate, and statistical argument upon a subject
of which she is wholly ignorant. A defence of this kind—supposing that
any defence was required—is positively hurtful to the parties whose
conduct has been called in question; and anything but creditable to
their discretion if they consented to its issue.
Interspersed with the actual narrative, are commentaries, or rather
criticisms, upon art and literature, which, for the sake of the
authoress, we could wish omitted. Her taste, upon all subjects of the
kind, is either wholly uncultivated or radically bad—indeed it would be
absolutely cruel to quote her observations on the works of the old
masters. In literature she prefers Dr Watts, as a poet, to Dryden, and
has the calm temerity to proceed to quotation. She says, “For instance,
take these lines:—
“‘Wide as his vast dominion lies
Let the Creator’s name be known;
Loud as his thunder shout his praise,
_And sound it lofty as his throne_.
Speak of the wonders of that love
_Which Gabriel plays on every chord_,
From all below and all above
Loud hallelujahs to the Lord.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account