Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
Beautiful aspirations—lovely lines! Why—they are absolute nonsense; and
the mere silent reading of them has set our teeth on edge. Try to recite
them, and you are inevitably booked for a catarrh! In like manner she
refers to some rubbish of Mr Whittier, an American rhymer, as a
“beautiful ballad, called ‘Barclay of Ury.’” We have a distinct
recollection of having read that ballad some years ago, and of our
impression that it was incomparably the worst which we ever encountered;
though, if a naked sword were at this moment to be presented to our
throat, we could depone nothing further, than that “rising in a fury,”
rhymed to “Barclay of Ury;” and also, that “frowning very darkly,”
chimed in to the name of “Barclay.” But it was woeful stuff; and it
lingers in our memory solely by reason of its absurdity. However, as Mrs
Stowe prefers this sort of thing to Spenser, we have nothing for it
except to make our bow, regretting that our æsthetical notions are so
far apart, that, under no circumstances whatever, can we foresee the
possibility of a coalition.
Beyond the Channel we shall not follow her; the more especially as the
greater part of the Continental tour is described in the journal of the
Rev. Charles Beecher, an individual with whose proceedings, thoughts,
and raptures, we have not been able to conjure up the slightest
sympathy. In fact, taking Mr Beecher at his own estimate and valuation,
and making every allowance for playfulness of manner, we should by no
means covet his company in any part of Europe; and we are only surprised
that, in one or two places (as for instance Cologne), he did not receive
an emphatic check to his outrageous hilarity. But as he seems to have
been impressed with the idea that he exhibited himself rather in a
humorous and attractive light, we have no intention of dispelling the
dream—we are only sorry that Mrs Stowe should have thought it worth
while to increase the bulk of her book by admitting her relative’s
inflated, ill-written, and singularly silly lucubrations, as part of a
work which, considering her literary celebrity, and the interest of the
theme, will in all probability have an extensive circulation.
After making every allowance for the difficulty attendant upon the task
of portraying with fidelity and spirit the customs of a foreign country,
we cannot, with truth, express an opinion that Mrs Stowe has been
successful in her effort. Far more interesting and agreeable volumes
have been written by women of less natural ability; and we are
constrained to dismiss, with a feeling of decided disappointment, a book
which we opened with the anticipation of a very different result.
THE CRYSTAL PALACE.[44]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account