Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
If Mr Jones colours the horses brown and grey, the faces of the riders
flesh colour, and marks their eyes, and reddens their lips, and
draperies their bodies after patterns out of a tailor’s book—it is quite
absurd to say that the Greeks never intended exact imitation. In what he
has done every one will recognise the attempt to portray exact nature in
colour. Upon this principle, and establishing a contempt of white
marble, there is but one more step to take, to set up offensive wax-work
above the art of the statuary in marble. Sculpture is an appeal to the
imagination, not to the senses. That which attempts to deceive disgusts
by the early discovery of the fraud. Indeed, it is a maxim in sculpture
that a certain unnaturalness in subordinate accompanying objects is to
be adopted, to show that a comparison with real nature is not intended.
“If imitation is to be preferred,” says Aristotle, “which is least
adapted to the vulgar and most calculated to please the politest
spectators, that which imitates everything is clearly most adapted to
the vulgar, as not being intelligible without the addition of much
movement and action, as bad players on the flute turn round, if they
would imitate the motion of a discus.” Paint to the statuary is what all
this motion is to the flute-player. Whoever mutilates what is great and
good in art, and would persist in so doing, after reproof, ought to pay
the penalty of his folly. We would not be too severe in the punishment
of offenders in taste, but should rejoice to see one of a congenial kind
put in practice, one very mild for such an offence as this of statue
painting—the tarring and feathering the perpetrators, plasterers and
bedaubers, principals and coadjutors. Upon Mr Owen Jones’s principle,
the “ex uno omnes,” and his making a confirmed summer of one swallow,
though we entirely deny the existence of this one _rara avis_, a white
marble statue painted, he and his company ought not to object to the
punishing process, for more culprits have been known to have been tarred
and feathered than are even the pretended specimens of painted marbles
on record. We would, out of consideration for the peculiar taste of the
decorators, mitigate the punishment, by allowing the received proportion
of Mr Jones’s blue and vermilion to be mixed with the tar.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account