Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
It is, we think, to be regretted that those who intend to lay before the
public their impressions of foreign travel, should so often have
recourse to the form of letters purporting to be addressed to friends or
relatives at home. We admit that, for purposes of fiction, the
epistolary style is convenient. Testy Mathew Bramble, his tyrannical
sister Tabitha, and the lovelorn Winifred Jenkins, may, by their several
lucubrations, unite to form the most amusing of family chronicles; but
Smollett, when he compiled _Humphrey Clinker_, took care that the
expression of each character should be perfectly natural. So with
Lever’s _Dodd Family_, and the immortal letters of Mrs Ramsbottom. But
the case of a party deliberately penning letters, in his or her own
name, not for the private gratification of a select circle, or the
information of those to whom they are addressed, but directly for the
press and the public, is very different. In the first place, every one
knows and feels that the letters are not genuine. The most gifted of our
race, in addressing a mother, a sister, or a child, do not think it
necessary to indulge in fine writing, or in long elaborate descriptions,
or in statistical details. They write simply—generally shortly; and a
good deal of their matter would, if submitted to the eye of a stranger,
appear to be unmeaning gossip, not improbably approaching to twaddle. We
doubt not that, in the real letters which Mrs Stowe despatched across
the Atlantic, there were many household inquiries, suggestions, and
remembrances—domestic precepts and home-thoughts—kind, motherly, or
friendly words, such as render letters doubly delightful to the
recipients. But these formal epistles which she has now given to the
world under the collective title of _Sunny Memories of Foreign Lands_,
bear falsity in their very face, and, in all human probability, the
printer’s devil was the first person that perused them. They are all
pitched in one key. Her despatches to the home nursery are as elaborate
efforts of composition, as those which are nominally addressed to her
father, or to “Dear Aunt E.”;—and, as a necessary consequence, they are
frigid in the extreme. This is an artistic blunder, which cannot fail to
detract very much from the interest of what Mrs Stowe had written. It
was not perhaps to be expected, nor indeed desired, that she should have
printed her genuine letters; but surely there was no occasion for
recasting her diary or memoranda in a purely fictitious form.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account