Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 76, No. 467, September 1854
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
And we can very well understand the intensity of the feeling
which must have thrilled Mrs Stowe, when she found that even in
sequestered villages in Scotland her work had been moistened with tears,
and that the people, on the announcement of her approach, thronged to
welcome the woman who had exercised so mighty a spell over their
intellect and their passions. There was, really, no delusion in the
matter, in so far as admiration of her talent and respect for her
intrepidity were concerned; but we may, at the same time, be allowed to
regret that she was made part of a premeditated pageant. The utter want
of delicacy which marked the whole arrangements was most extraordinary.
We are sure that Mrs Stowe must have been surprised, if not disgusted,
at finding herself announced as ready to receive deputations and
addresses at certain stated hours, and at the invitation of crowds to
attend in order to cheer her at railway stations. There is something
elevating in spontaneous enthusiasm, even when it is carried beyond the
limits of strict propriety; but demonstrations such as those to which we
have alluded, are not only unfair to the party paraded, but border
closely on the ludicrous. No quackery of the kind was required to insure
Mrs Stowe a cordial reception in Scotland; and we fear that in some
respects it operated rather to her disadvantage than otherwise.
We confess to have been greatly disappointed in the perusal of her
northern tour. We had expected to derive some amusement, if not
edification, from the remarks of a lady whose previous publications had
manifested considerable power in the depiction of character, not unmixed
with occasional glimpses of humour; the more especially as there is much
in the northern idiosyncrasy which must appear peculiar in the eyes of a
stranger. Nothing of the sort, however, is to be found in the pages of
Mrs Stowe. Read her work, omitting the familiar names of places, and one
would be utterly at a loss to suppose that she is describing Scotland
and its inhabitants either outwardly or inwardly. Saunders, as she
depicts him, is a sort of sentimental Treddles, minding every body’s
business more than his own, intoning peace speeches on a platform with a
strong nasal twang, and refreshing himself, after his labours, with
oceans of the weakest and the worst of tea. It is ten thousand pities
that Mrs Stowe should not have witnessed either a Lowland kirn or a
regular Highland meeting. Possibly the sounds either of fiddle or of
bagpipe might have grated harshly on her ear; and the “twasome” reel or
that of Houlakin been regarded as forbidden vanities; still she would
have been infinitely the better of some more diversified experience,
which might at least have caused her to avoid the error of depicting us
as a nation of Mucklewraths, Hammeryaws, and Kettledrummles. As for her
outward sketches, we must say that we greatly prefer the ordinary
guide-books. They have at least the merit of being concise, and do not
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account