Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 93, No. 571, May, 1863Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 93, No. 571, May, 1863
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
It is not probable that many of our readers will meet with the volumes,
lately published in Washington, containing the correspondence of
American diplomatists during the period of the civil war; but, after
perusing some of the specimens we shall offer, they will no doubt agree
with us in thinking it a pity that these productions should not be
generally known. Under any circumstances, most people would find
something comical in a set of elderly gentlemen, engaged in important
business, exchanging by letter moral sentiments suited to a schoolboy’s
theme. But when the compositions thus embellished are of the kind known
to the world as State Papers, and when the writers, who thus aim, like
the interlocutors in a religious novel, at the instruction of the
universe through the medium of dialogue, are American politicians, the
effect produced is such as few professed humorists could hope to rival.
For most people are aware nowadays that the atmosphere through which
those politicians must pass before they can attain to that eminence, one
condition of which is the writing of state papers, is much more likely
to develop in them the wisdom of the serpent than the guilelessness of
the dove. Remembering the pushing and scrambling, the elbowing of vile
competitors, the truckling and corruption, the wire-pulling and
log-rolling, the acquaintance with all the small and dirty ramifications
of tickets and platforms, which success in politics demands in the
States, the very last vein of composition we should expect to find these
gentlemen especially cultivating would be that in which the sage Imlac
addresses Rasselas, or in which the good godmother improves every
occasion in a children’s story. A difficulty to believe in the existence
of craft or guile or self-interest as motives of political conduct,
yielding at last to a surprised and mournful conviction of the sad
truth, and a touching and simple style of moralising over human
delinquency, are the characteristics, on paper, of the diplomatists who
have particularly distinguished themselves in the pleasing and pastoral
pursuits we have attempted to enumerate. Everybody who has read American
speeches must have noticed in them a tendency to flowery sentiment and
to ancient and fish-like metaphors, such as the audiences of the Old
World would reject. Why the not very immaculate or poetical classes who
constitute a New York mob should especially relish this style of
oratory, we cannot explain; but it is the fact that it seems to succeed
in America whether the audience be a constituency, or a house of
assembly, or the population of a Boston lecture-room, or the
entertainers of an American celebrity, or a jury in a criminal case—and
all the scribes of their newspapers indulge in the same vein. That it
does succeed may appear to be a sufficiently good reason why the
parliamentary and stump orators of America should habitually launch at
their audiences such sentences as are, on this side of the water, never
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account